PatKDay's Comments

Comment

Endless Expansion

Play Endless Expansion

Dec. 28, 2015

Rating: 3

I think this game is a pretty interesting take on the idle game concept. I actually like that it feels a bit like a puzzle game since you can't cross roads, cables, or pipes. I don't know if this was purely intentional, but it does add a major mechanic to the game. In fact, I think that I would like to see all the storage, accumulator, and reservoir buildings get nerfed by removing the resource "teleportation" ability. To compensate, I would make the roads, cables, and pipes much cheaper. Not only would this emphasis the puzzle aspects of the game, it would allow more room to add upgraded buildings that do allow for unconnected transportation of resources (for example, a shipping port that must be built in water and connects resources to any other shipping port on the same body of water).

Destination Kepler

Play Destination Kepler

Dec. 24, 2015

Rating: 4

To elaborate on a previous post, I hate constantly moving crew around. You should be able to set priorities/percentages so that it's mostly automated. Let's say you have 100 crew and set the percentage to 50% research, 25% mining, and 25% healing. The simple distribution would give 50, 25, and 25 crew members to the three tasks respectively. Then if you go on a mission that requires 50 crew, it would automatically redistribute to 25, 13, and 12 crew members for those tasks. Even better would be if it was smart enough to remove crew from medical if there's no injured crew and distribute them evenly (based on %) to the other two tasks. I think that would be a great additional, but the bad part is that it would really highlight how little there is for the player to do since 95% of the time spent playing the game is merely moving crew from one task to another.

Destination Kepler

Play Destination Kepler

Dec. 24, 2015

Rating: 5

Seemed like a fun little game at first, but then I realized there aren't any real choices. Completely linear upgrade path, extremely repetitive gameplay, and a less than ideal user interface. It would be greatly improved if the upgrades had more variety and different gameplay mechanics such as slow mining laser with greater yield, etc.

Momentum Missile Mayhem 2015

Play Momentum Missile Mayhem 2015

Sep. 30, 2015

Rating: 5

Ok, there's no way for me to describe this game other than janky. Controls are kinda crap, the challenges are poorly balanced, and menus/in-game tool tips are terrible. Considering this went straight to hot new games, I'm surprised by just how unfinished it feels. 2/5

Strikeforce Kitty: Last Stand

Play Strikeforce Kitty: Last Stand

Jun. 22, 2015

Rating: 2

I don't to pile on with the negative reviews, but there's nothing good to say about this game. It's not a good upgrade or defense game and it's not even a good idle game.

Kill the Plumber

Play Kill the Plumber

May. 19, 2015

Rating: -4

If the goal is to create a sluggish, boring game to make me feel sorry for the bad guys in Mario games then I guess good job. Still, it's not what I call fun. 2/5

Tap Heroes

Play Tap Heroes

Mar. 10, 2015

Rating: -11

This in not an idle game because it requires too much interaction(i.e manual gold gathering). Unfortunately, the interaction is shallow and boring so it's not a very good active game either. In order to improve the game, it really needs to focus on making the interaction faster and more meaningful. It does have a very good art style, but in the end, this feels like the prototype testing of an iOS game where you're going to have to pay cash money to get gems. 2/5

Last Town

Play Last Town

Jan. 15, 2015

Rating: 15

Each levels seems to start the same way - way too slow. And then each level ends the same - way too fast. Once you start getting a bunch of troops the battlefield becomes unmanageable. The game would be helped tremendously with a pause menu (where you can still place troops and use powers) as well as a speed up button. Additionally, I like if when you do the pause feature, it lets you see the grid without troops getting in the way.

Epic Time Pirates

Play Epic Time Pirates

Dec. 23, 2014

Rating: 3

I absolutely hate having to depend on terrible AI to win the matches. CTF and Control Points are the worst. 2/5

Galaxy Harvest

Play Galaxy Harvest

Dec. 02, 2014

Rating: 6

This game has a lot of potential, but it's lacking in a number of ways. First, the level of precision control just isn't there. I want the ability to select multiple planets and set system wide defaults (such as the auto harvest or suppress %). Second, the information provide is weak. I want more details in the mini-map such as planet color-coding. Third, I need some way to setup up proactive defense around the HQ and planets. Finally, the atrophy is just too high from negative events (which greatly out number the positive events). It seems like the system falls part faster than I can complete the objectives specifically on the hard setting. I really like the concept, but currently the game is a 3/5.

Rogue Legend: Tame the Wild

Play Rogue Legend: Tame the Wild

Nov. 19, 2014

Rating: 6

This game would be a perfect 5/5 if the inventory management was more streamline. I spend half of each just running back and forth between chests or swapping things around in my backpacks. A few things that would be HUGE improvements: 1) Larger backpacks that hold double/triple the amount; 2) Items in backpacks/chests in crafting area automatic get shown in crafting lists so you don't have to manually move them around; 3) Inventory slots for items that you never swap out (swords, armor, backpack, canteen, etc)

Developer response from HelpIMadeAGame

I've added bigger backpacks and using items in them while crafting :)

Besieged 2 Infinite

Play Besieged 2 Infinite

Nov. 14, 2014

Rating: 1

This game is the opposite of fun. Slow, repetitive, grindy, and annoying controls.

Hut Take Control 2

Play Hut Take Control 2

Oct. 08, 2014

Rating: 11

This game is absolutely terrible. I honestly can't remember a worse game on Kongregate. Side note - It seems like Kong has really dived the last couple of years. All the games are garbage paid games or junk like this.

Tesla Defense 2

Play Tesla Defense 2

Aug. 28, 2014

Rating: -6

Wow, this game is terrible.

Royal Warfare

Play Royal Warfare

Jul. 10, 2014

Rating: 0

I wanted to like this game, but I just don't feel like my actions make any difference to the outcome. Basically, the game comes down to how you allocate upgrades for the upcoming battle because you have almost no control. Targeting enemies is a hassle and typically doesn't work anyway because it seems like my troops never go where I want them to. It definitely lacks the precision I want in a RTS-lite game.

Up in the Sky

Play Up in the Sky

Jun. 25, 2014

Rating: 1

I normally really like these types of games, but this one never really came together for me. I felt that the results were too random and that the player isn't really given a fair chance to avoid obstacles or collect power ups. Combined with the somewhat grindy gameplay, it is only a 3/5 for me.

Last Legacy: Null Space

Play Last Legacy: Null Space

Jun. 22, 2014

Rating: 3

I have no idea what to do on the 8th dimension. After I hit the button to flip the gravity, I can't jump back up the ice. Is there some sort of trick I'm missing or do I need just need to struggle through the ice jumping?

Solarmax 2

Play Solarmax 2

Jun. 14, 2014

Rating: 4

I've almost beat the whole game on hard and I feel that the AI is challenging but fair except in one case - Level 33. Level 33 is the only level I can only beat on easy. I've probably attempted 33 twenty time on medium and hard difficultly, but I can't do it.

Solarmax 2

Play Solarmax 2

Jun. 13, 2014

Rating: 3

I was really liking the game up until level 33 and then it just plain stopped being fun. The black AI shows up and just destroys me. It would almost be alright, if the other enemy AIs would band together to help the black, but no.... I'm fighting to save my live and the other AIs attack me instead of the black AI ensuring mutual destruction for us all.

Nether Runner

Play Nether Runner

Jun. 06, 2014

Rating: 22

By default, the player moves too slow to avoid the first bosses attacks. I'm not saying that I'm an expert at bullet hell games, but I'm usually ok. This game seems that you flat out can't beat the first boss without some serious upgrades to speed first.