PS3? I’m no fanboy so enjoy both, though my 360 did get RRoD once. And it can’t play Blu-rays. Plus I’m cheap so PSN wins that contest. At the end of the day, my PS3 gets the most face time, but not because I don’t like my 360!
The most botched video game story? I think this must be a trick question given the ME3 controversy. But I’ll say it’s a toss up given that most games IMO fail in the story department.