IAFish

The graphics are top notch and gameplay is smooth. I think you have what could be a good game. But right now I find the karma system to be frustrating. Minnows are necessary, and virtually unavoidable. Yet they seemed to decrease my karma, which eventually killed me. I could be wrong about that but that's how it seemed. The other karma issue is the frequency of available fish. You should try and implement a system which increases the the number of fish the player prefers. Right now it seems like the game will end no matter what the player does. Any good game needs to be designed to reward success and strategy.

Good coding, great graphics, but the game-play needs some work to be fun.

the karma thing is very problematic. Since there is no control over when your fish eats - you cannot move without 'eating' the minnows after they have a karmic penalty.

Either remove the karmic penalty for eating minnows, or make them much, much better at fleeing when you get that size.

I like the fact that you are trying to go beyond the usual fish eat fish game, and the graphics are great, but the karma thing as it is now makes the game more frustrating than fun.

Well executed but I have to echo the karma thing sucks. My experience seems to indicate that it drops unless one is eating something of the right size, even avoiding the minnows it still drops and the right size fish don't come often enough to counteract it.

cool game, karma doesnt really fit in to well with the concept tho. becomes quickly impossible

Yeah, I can't seem to effect the karma either