So... I'm genuinely curious. Who lied? Who was "she"? I've played through the fourth episode and I have no idea who you were referrng to -- I thought there would be some great reveal of a HORRIBLE PAST wherein he slaughtered someone who falsely admitted to being a witch (knowngly). Perhaps because the brown guy's sudden appearance seemed design to KILL YOU. Little bastard kept me up at night.
I was kind of disappointed that this wasn't clarified -- and would lovet to learn more about this world.