If the achievement won't update for you go back to the menu and try colored mode. It unlocked both the achievements when I did that after I accomplished the achievements.
The next one should be Papa's Cannibalium, in which Papa goes nuts and becomes a serial killer. Your job is to help cover up Papa's misdeeds by serving his victims up as lunch to unsuspecting fast food customers.
I gave it a 5/5 but I'd like to know how many calories I burned at the end of the game as well as what I got the confetti level up to. Not knowing these is potentially game breaking imho, but I dealt with (by whining about it on the comments, but dealing with it no less).
Between this and the turtle smashing game... the turtle smashing game wins. Sorry, but coming up with a super awesome turtle smashing combo knocks the socks off this. I mean the guy has a business suit and a giant hammer - there is just no beating that! =O
 "Fade"){kind=icon}
 "Papa's Taco Mia!"){kind=icon}
 "Treadmillasaurus Rex"){kind=icon}
 "Air Pressure"){kind=icon}
 "ClueSweeper"){kind=icon}
 "Circle Max"){kind=icon}
 "The Necronomicon"){kind=icon}