I liked how every level was short and straightforward, and you could easily figure out what it is you were supposed to do to finish the level. That being said, level 55-57 really ruined the game for me. While 55 could have been finished quickly, the time it took to figure it out changed the pace of the game dramatically in a very bad way. 56 was especially annoying because it wasn't clear to me where the exit even was. Also, I really liked how the entire level fit on the same screen - which is why level 57 was the game-breaker for me. I wasn't expecting the game to become a side-scroller, which I found to be extremely frustrating.
The fact that you're providing continued support/updates even after the release of the game is very awesome. More games need to have dedicated developers like you.
The player should have more control over the physics in this game. It's difficult to aim properly even after resetting the level multiple times. In addition, there are too many levels in which people become safely nested under the castle pieces, thus preventing you from completing the level.
After playing so much of the later Papa games, I've picked up some bad habits. I keep clicking over the customer's head when I want to take an order, and I always forget to press the Make Pizza Button and expect it to be sitting there when I start making it.
Awesome game once you figure out what to do. 1.) When he is close to you, attack him until you see his beard move, then dodge his attack. 2.) When he moves to the side, he will laser the top row, then the bottom row. During this time, attack from bottom, then attack from top. (Note: The middle platform is not high enough to dodge the bottom laser.) 3.) When he exits the top of the screen, he will throw bread down at you. Stand under a platform, then let the bread bounce and dodge after. 4.) He also has an attack where he rotates his beard and chases you, although he seems to use it randomly. 5.) The skull only has one attack, it will shoot fireballs in all 8 directions on the left, right, then middle of the screen in that order. If you stand on the bumps on the lower levels, his fireballs can't hit you as long as you're not next to him. You can use this time to fully charge your magic. Stay away from his attack, then attack during his cool down period.
If you are having trouble getting the 'Sniper' badge, you can replay the same level repeatedly by dying, and the head shots you get will count towards your total. Combined with the 99 Hunting Rifle Glitch from KhAoTiiKz's comment, the badge is pretty easy to get.
If I ever make a game in which it takes longer than 1/4 of a second to respawn, you have permission to slap me.