kay few things, if you want to fix this game or improve your next. You should make each level a different scene so that you can put in the replay actionscript. that way instead of starting ALL the way at the beginning you can just make it so only that lvl is restarted. Also some things that aren't REAL problems, but are still annoying; you should move the cursor to the front of the layers, cuz as it is, you can put the cursor behind buttons which looks weird. im not great at actionscript, but i know stuff, so if you want you can add me or ask me about anything you want.
repetitive, but otherwise not tooo bad, although i think that the badge for getting 7 castles completed should be hard, cuz even tho the castles themselves arent that hard, getting to them is.
3.5 maybe 4/5
this comment isnt going to be for or against the removal of the game, but from a critical veiwpoint this game is lacking in originality, graphics and hacking prevention. this has nothing to do with the fact that i dont personally like it, but i would not rate this game very highly anyways. The only way this game should even deserve to stay on this website, or even in usage, is if it didnt require payments to play the game to its full extent. (but i very much doubt jagex would even think of getting rid of the paying feature.)