A lot of my comments have been covered, but I have two specific complaints (that should be in all TDs) that could probably be easily patched: you need health bars (even if optional) on the units (no, clicking on them doesn't count) and you need a visual guide to show you the current upgraded level of the tower. Would be much appreciated improvements to an otherwise solid, if slightly uninspired, game. 4/5.
Beautiful and fun artistic game. Please don't give much thought to the haters here if they have no legit criticism to provide. We need more games like this. Bravo.
Henshin - there are some Shmups where you wouldn't (Ikaruga is the best example I can think of, both for combos and for not hitting the wrong enemy type), but this isn't one of them. :)
Please do not post surveys in game comments. It does not help your case and only serves to ruin the comments board for everyone else. We will certainly look into getting badges for this game, but we also will likely be deleting these obnoxious, even if well-meaning, surveys.
I really want to like this game, but there are a few things holding it back for me. First: mouse controls. Perhaps I'm just old school, but these games are made for keys, not mice. At least give the choice. Second, hit box. Too weird - back of the gun would be better, and highlighted would be nice. Third, the stat calculations are odd (better attributes lower my stats??) and there's no info on the game screen about what XP or gold things are worth or how close you are to a new level. If the UI were improved I could really dig this game, but right now it feels unpolished. Still, 4/5 for good quality.
Ooh, an oldie (I remember this from at least a year ago, if not 2), but a goody. Glad to see it made it to Kongregate. I'm surprised it wasn't hear already.
Pretty cool TD - a welcome addition to the collection. Though shame on your for not giving credit to the source that you very obviously heavily based this game on: Immortal Defense. :-P
Nice concept, but I wish you had done more with it. I was done with the whole game in about 20 minutes and most of it just felt like prodding and poking without much purpose. Level 19 was easily my favorite (very clever!) but most of the rest of it was kinda forgettable and repetitive. Still, fun while it lasted and well made, a solid 4/5.
Actually, it's not an English-only site, but most users are English-speakers, so games take a risk that people won't play them if they're not in English. Still, we're not going to take it down for that, and there's also nothign wrong with being an ad for a retail game. Please rate games based on the quality, not based on trivial side characteristics.
Beautiful, gorgeous game that controls very nicely and is a joy to play. Doesn't overstay its welcome, offers challenge and fun, is amazingly animated, has a cool boss...I'm not sure what more one could ask for from a video game. Let's just say it's 2am, I finally got my 150th mushroom, and I had no intention of staying up this late. An emphatic 5/5. Thank you.
Great game. Similar to what's been done before, but an excellent twist and some great puzzles. Well done! Would highly recommend implementing the API - you'll almost certainly be up for monthly contest winning. 4/5 :)
One simple but helpful change to make - the Reset Level button is in the middle, while the Try Again button is on the left. Consistency in here would lead to many fewer mis-clicks from me.
I don't particularly like this genre of games. They've been done numerous times and it's not really for me. That said, this is clearly the best of the bunch, with excellent presentation, incorporation of upgrades, and cool graphics and performance. I don't like the game, but that's just me. Still gets a 5/5 out of respect for the quality of it. :)
This happens occasionally when HDG has a glitch on their site - apparently their preloader checks the site for validity of the version. In any case, it's had glitches like this before and should (hopefully) come back soon. If it doesn't we'll look into it further. Until then, go play something else. Or go outside. :)
Entertaining idea, and well executed all around, except on the game itself. It's unclear whether or not this was intentional, but frankly in either case I can't rate it a 5/5. 4/5 for a fun concept and good implementation of most elements, but with a weak game...meh. And sure, your point is that there's more to games than upgrades, but you're foolishly implying that upgrades completely diminish the quality of a game, which I find to be simply false. A meld of gameplay with a sense of development and progression is ideal. In any case, an interesting experiment, and while somewhat exploitive I still look forward to your next game.
Sadly, GameJacket went out of business and their games are all busted. :( The developers are going to have to make some significant changes before it's going to work again.
Nice bridge physics game, and well done in Flash. However, the game suffers from being very slow, especially on longer levels. It's useful to see how the bridges collapse, but the addition of a x3 key or button would really help when you have to retry a level you just sat through - really hurts the otherwise excellent experience. Honestly, drops to a 4/5 for me, but would be a 5/5 with a speed-up button to reduce the tediousness.
The game is pretty typical for a defense game honestly. But the presentation is perhaps the best of any defense game on this entire website. Excellent animation and art style, good voice acting, and a risky though successful portrayal of having the player as a Nazi soldier - I'm not sure that I've seen that done in a non-hateful manner before. Very well done - I look forward to your next project. 5/5.
This game has a lot of potential, and I really want to like it, but it lacks variety of challenge. Every level (so far, I'm on level 7) is exactly the same. You start with the same money, get the same customers, have the same building options...there's nothing new at all. It has a really cool model for shopping and nice representation of it, but sadly ends up becoming essentially just a really long game of Simon. I'd give it 3/5 at the moment, but could easily be a 4 or 5 with some tweaking of the levels and challenges.
 "Bloons Tower Defense 4"){kind=icon}
 "mini Tower Defence (mTD)"){kind=icon}
 "Icycle"){kind=icon}
 "Enigmata"){kind=icon}
 "Ultimate Assassin 2"){kind=icon}
 "Flood Fill"){kind=icon}
 "SkyFyre"){kind=icon}
 "Antbuster"){kind=icon}
 "Paper War"){kind=icon}
 "Demolition City"){kind=icon}
 "FUUN! DAIROJO Trial Ver （JAPANESE TD）"){kind=icon}
 "William and Sly"){kind=icon}
 "Red Remover"){kind=icon}
 "Phage Wars 2"){kind=icon}
 "Desktop Tower Defense 1.5"){kind=icon}
 "UPGRADE COMPLETE!"){kind=icon}
 "Bloony Wheel"){kind=icon}
 "Cargo Bridge"){kind=icon}
 "D-Day Defender"){kind=icon}
 "Shopping Street"){kind=icon}