All 68 fish: http://www.thepoxbox.com/tests/fishies.jpg
How to get a Mako shark:
1. Go to Bimivi Wreck stage
2. Any FAST and LARGE dark black or dark grey spot will be a mako shark or a very large blacktip shark
3. If you do not see one within 3 seconds, go to the map and come back to Bimivi to respawn fishes
4. Sharks will instantly go for your bait so as soon as it gets near, be ready to click away on the mouse to snag it.
Then it's practice. Pay attention to fish states:
- normal = don't touch anything if you're "secure", the pointer will remain in the center
- angry = single-reel to keep it in the "secure" zone
- tired = double-reel to bring it back to "secure"
NEVER STOP REELING FROM THE SLACK ZONE UNTIL THE POINTER IS BACK IN THE SECURE ZONE.
Keep the pointer on the far-left of the SECURE zone when the fish isn't doing anything.
If the fish hit the far-left of the STRESS zone, DON'T TOUCH ANYTHING until the pointer comes back to the SECURE zone.
 "Super Fishing"){kind=icon}
 "Anatomy Challenge part"){kind=icon}
You say that, but I know for fact that you've caught more than three Makos before, ya dingus :D