Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Definitely needs a tutorial. There are way too many aspects of the game for a player to grasp on the first few games and be successful. Different levels of difficulty would be great as well. Many people will get frustrated at the awesome p0wnage they'll be subject to the first couple of games they play. One star until that gets fixed.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
a pretty good concept but needs to be altered a bit. needs a save. needs a better control over generals. needs better balance of resources or higher / more build tiles, needs a tutorial, especially with the attack mode - i figured it out but it's a bit strange and i also noticed if i was invading somewhere and at the sametime was being invaded then it totally glitched up. 3/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Alot of potential here!! I beat the game in 111 days. It needs to be more challenging. I could have pron beat waaaay before that. Needs some work with a few bugs and it would be a 5/5 instead of 4/5. Bugs I noticed is when I am attacked at home sometimes I fight with a wall... sometimes not.... I got the temple to lvl 9 and still couldnt create divine soldiers.... i took over camps and did not see where any "special" soldiers could be created... I did not lose any battles and completely dominated... why do I get so much money? I can buy my way through this entire game!! Needs a save function... when I beat the game no high score board... need to be able to redirect troops from one battlefield to the next.... plus much much more... I hope this is a beta version!!!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The combat system is both pointless and boring. The lack of instructions makes the game incredibly difficult and all in all it is a pretty poor game. 1/5.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Hints would be great! I've been trying and trying at this game and always loosing in week 4/5. I've learnt one thing though! Use the market!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Very interesting, and well-executed for the most part.
Only major points of note are the lack of a city wall repair function (outside of the fixed-rate regeneration) and the buggy general selection (generals who shouldn't be there show up on the list during combat).
I enjoyed it. Well done.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Hey does anyone know what increases gold so i can upgrade it. good game combat needs hints and i to smashing by the other team in about 10 mins with them havig horses and like 100 of all the other solders wile i had about 15 of each :L 4/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Also, add some more possible players (Water, Earth).
The graphics are good, though. And the gameplay is okay. This kinda stuff could get 1 mil plays if you fix some things.
There's a lot of bugs, though - If you fire a general, they'll still reappear on the battle screen when you're defending the city. When you withdraw your troops from an occupied area, you still get your bonuses from that spot even though no one's there.
And when you get attacked while you're in another battle, it gets confusing (keeps on switching between the battles).
And more powers and buildings would be nice.
Also, wood is overuseful. Switch it so that more buildings need more stone than wood.
And there should be a tech that speeds up the time it takes to research a tech.
Apart from that, the game was still pretty fun. 4/5 (5 if you add a tutorial and fix some bugs).
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
OK.... I have tried playing this game three times now, and I have to say that it really needs two things: 1) a save function, and 2) instructions/hints. Having to try to rush on building things that may or may not be useful, only to always end up being killed by some massive invading army without any real warning is ridiculous. Also, why should I be dead if my walls are still standing, just because the army ran out? If nothing else, I should have the option of making more. 2/5 for now...
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I hate this game. How come I can't make the stupid fire spirit? I've met all the requirments, so what the hell is the problem?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Its not bad. My main gripe is combat. It is not explained at all and is too expensive to figure out via trial and error. It shows promise though and I will be eagerly awaiting updates.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
This game is ridiculously easy, once you realise that you can buy all your resources whenever you need them, you just pump troops out of your ass until you win.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
This would be a great game if not for all the bugs and lack of instruction. 2/5... easy 5/5 if the problems are dealt with
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Not sure if I'm missing something -- after first few wall upgrades, the wall itself stopped appearing in battle. Battles in my home city took place out in the open, with no traps/wall/etc. That was frustrating. Otherwise, with a save/help/and bug-fix upgrade, this game would be very nice! After a few false starts got the hang of it, and AI became very easy to defeat.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Must be able to save + would be nice to be able to see where troops are on the world view. The "die after you're attacked and are out of troops" is also annoying... 3/5