Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Interesting concept, would be cool to be able to do things with what you've made... I can see a TD coming from this sort of thing... maybe thats just GemCraft. Possible just have a graphic in the background of your 'planet' that slowly changes based on what you've made... ?
Anyway, would be good to not be able to mix things you've already tried... have them bounce back and say "Element Exists" or something... also, amaybe having a "*/10" type option beside the categories you've found.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Also, it would be a little bit better if the combinations were intuitive, as opposed to pairs that "kinda-sorta have maybe a little to do with each other."
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
3 moreeeeeeeeeeee freakin annoyin tryin to figure them all out!!! have to wait for the light bulb almost every time after 80
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
finally finished, a few hours done!
but now it wont let me click the submit button, 6420 isn't bad i suppose!
5/5 it was a ton of fun and can't wait for the next installment!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
i think a big improvement would be to show a percentage of how complete each group was. that way, you kind of know where to focus your attention
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I would really like it if after I combined something it went back to the 2 categories instead of me having to go back manually
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
sand + storm should be sand storm fire + storm should be fire storm and electricity + storm should be lightening storm
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I really think you should expand on this using the many ideas in these comments, and include a number of joke elements for parody and humorous purposes (such as sex + fire = Kings of Leon, or at least an obvious dig at their group without mentioning them for copyright purposes...) and perhaps being able to visit the world as it evolves with all the new items on it. You could even have certain items not allowed until others are created... like no cars and such until humans have been made, and perhaps being able to gain experience from creations in order to foresee future items, and then figuring out how to make them (which would be an improved hint system based on reward). There's a ton you could do for a 2nd version, and I'd very much like to see it. 4/5 as it stands though!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Oddly addictive, and I didn't stop until I found all combinations just to find out what they were. I wish I'd known for the first 90 or so elements that you could drag... I was confused as to why it would think I was combining two of the same but it was detecting my clicking as quickly drag dropping onto the same tile occasionally. However, dragging is much easier than clicking everything once.