Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Idle Train 2

« Back to Idle Train 2

Stashiv

Mar. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) No offline progress? Not much of an idle game

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

It´s also far from finished. There is a lot else to do before I implement stuff that happens while no one plays.

Der_Chris

Mar. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I really liked it... until I refreshed. Progress of a day gone. No save... at least when reloading while rebuilding. Yay me.

+ - !

(3)

Developer response from Brachiales

What version of the game was it? I´d also like to know OS + browser. The game is suposed to save but it seems to fail for some users. How I try to get a workaround that irons out some of the possible reasons for the problem. You should not loose your save while rebuilding. It saves just before that menu opens. So you would have your old train and all stats as you open the game again.

BrainyExo

Mar. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) cute little time waster, i like trains

+ - !

(1)

Deadl0ck

Mar. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) The incredible slow progress, and lack of offline progression make me wonder how this has a 3.2 rating. It's an interesting concept, but it is WAY too slow to be fun.

+ - !

(2)

HeliogabaluF

Mar. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) On rebuild you are allowed to spend more tokens than you actually own. You will then start with negative gold, but not much.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

Thanks for that info. That´s ofc not supposed to happen.

Kajsa

Mar. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Fun little game. But I miss that water stop thingy they used to refuel their water tanks.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

There will be water towers later on. I just have to draw them first. Right now Im busy with fixing bugs and polishing the stuff I already made.

Roku1234

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) The one thing I hope for in any idle game is a save function. Sadly, coming back a day later and expecting there to be some progress has put me off.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

Ok you are the second one now. It has ofc autosave however it seems like it does not work for everyone. Sadly I do n´t know why. I did putt in an error handler yesterday it should send a message to text box on top of the screen if writing or reading fails. Did anything show up there? Also please send me a PM with OS and Browser you use. Also please consider trying another browser. That helps me to diagnose the problem.

bowserbabe

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) That is the most inefficient mail car I have ever seen.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

You see that´s not meant to be single letters. It´s like a freight unit like a barrel or a tonne.

gkennedy2014

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) What is does your xp and lvl do for you in the game?

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from Brachiales

Right now it does unly unlock new wagons. The last one at level 125 for now. But there will be more soon.

Baconalacarte

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I love when you see Bricks are selling for 6 gold, so you buy bricks and 30 seconds later, you're at 3 gold. And it never goes back to 6.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

You had just one brick cart ore several of them? I wlli have a loock at the algorythm there later today.

basement_dweller

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Here is a winning formula: The Grinder loco (14xp) + 5xp coal tender, max em out to grind levels alone. Earning gold and slower levelling - same loco combo, one passenger cart and as many coffee carts you can muster before rebuilding. You will make your passenger neurotic, addicted and you'll need to hire a toilet attendant, but it'll be worth it. Coffee adds the least drag and weight. 6 carts and 5000 gold = +11 steam thingies. Rebuild often to build up your steam cap.

+ - !

(12)

Kotasirith

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I did not know I could upgrade the engine because it said click the wagons to upgrade them and I read that to mean only wagons get upgraded, oops.

+ - !

(1)

uchik_2

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) auto save doesn't work. win10 firefox 64bit

+ - !

(1)

Brachiales

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) If your train stops moving at all please send me a PM with the following info: Wagons, Locomotive, Tender and the max speed displayed on the top left. From the train stat panel id like to know the powe, drag and weight. I´ll make a quick work around right now. Should be up soon

+ - !

(1)

jaro2009

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) is my train supposed to not move at all if i have too much weight/drag?

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

No it´s not. But I heard that before. DO you know what combo of Locomotive/Tender and wagons you have? Id also like to know what your max speed is and the Drag/weight and power value from the train stats. Would be nice if you could send it as a PM

cxxcz000

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Maybe some chilling background music so it wasent so "empty" and/or sound effects when the train starts n stops and when you pick up coins or other stuff

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from Brachiales

Music is something I wanted to have in it at the start, however, that might take time since I have just other priorities right now. Like fixing what´s there and make more content. I suggest you pick your own track on Youtube for now. I do have some sound effects around from former games, I guess I could putt them in this week. I avoided it at first because of performance reasons but it seems to run pretty smooth so far so I reconsider that.

TerryL44

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) So just bought a car and now my train is stuck, guess the load is too heavy and no rebuild button atm, need a way to avoid this from happening please

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

Ok that seems to be a thing now. I dive into it. please telle my your combo of Wagons/Tender and locommotive as PM. Also I´d like to now what "max speed" it shows.

marklone

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Game is amazing but sadly so few upgrades for 1st locomotive.If i upgrade 1st locomotive i have feeling i did all and it seems kinda pointless to wait any longer.I wish you continue to add new features.PLs dont leave this game.It has amazing potential.YOu can add new trains maybe.Something like train tycoon.I wish there was no limit on lvls ;.;, or maybe more lvls for things.When you get to lvl 10 game becomes fun and it feels like it ends in same way.XD Keep good work

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

There will be more stuff soon. I just want to get rid of bugs first and Improve what´s there so far. I will continue to add wagons and stuff soon. I plan to add Slots to wagons that can carry additional modifications. That allows to tune single attributes from the wagons. That´s one of the reasons why the level caps are rather low. But as mentioned in another comment, I also plan to add global upgrades some of them allow to raise the level cap for some wagon types.

Dracariys

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Since it's too slow at the benigging and can be quite annoying, make a few tries by placing a /2 multiplier to all costs. Place a clickable button somewere that can be spam-clicked to give some boost to the train, this will add something to do other than waiting. Rework the yellow bar thing, it is not intuitive. Add the reward when you reach the station and make the freight spawn on the ground where the locomotive can auto-pick up. Don't make the upgrade window full-screen unless you need to.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

It´s really just that slow at the beginning. As soon as you have a few steam tokens things get faster. There will be more to do later on. Since I plan to implement some wagons that provide mini-games. The yellow bar fills after 100m and triggers several things like filling up freight and selling goods in Shop wagons. The window needs that size for content that´s not live yet.

SzyszakS

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) it will be nice to see how big upgrade is (stats what change in next lvl)

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

That will come later. The next update brings at least a bit more information.

harbingerv1

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) yep... still resetting my progress... Most uptodate version of Windows.. and on Firefox... on an Alienware....

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

I really don´t get my head around that one so far. Did you try another browser? Is there any software that might prevent the game from writing to your disk? I will implement a check in the next update. So when it fails to write it should diaplzy something in the Text field at the top.

marzapower

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) It's 1 January 11805 here. We still drive using wood.

+ - !

(0)

wwwwebster

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Possible train station upgrade for more passengers?

+ - !

(36)

Developer response from Brachiales

The idea sounds good. I´ll putt this on the list. I plan to make upgrades for stations and the world/scene in general. However, there will be a separate currency for those. But there are still many things I want to implement before. Rigth now you get more passengers from wagon upgrades. I did not explain that in the game but you get more passengers in average if you upgrade the passenger wagons. Every time you visit a station you get a random amount of passengers between 1+Wagonlevel -> max passengers. I guess it´s time to work on those information windows.

wwwwebster

Mar. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I wish there was some sort of map so you can see where you are at

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from Brachiales

Well, you see the thing is you are kinda nowhere, always. At least right until you aproach a station. It just get´s a random name in that very moment. How ever, I plan to make sort of a real world later on. With different landscapes and so on. That´s a lot of artwork and that´s we it stands on the long bench for now.

Foerby1212

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) It seems you got some great ideas for the game! Keep on going!!!

+ - !

(24)

Developer response from Brachiales

Nice to hear, thank you. I´m still on it. There should be another upgrade in a few hours if things run smoth.

CassyM

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) When I got a new train I started with no coins and when I finally managed to add a cart the train didn't move at all. Is this a bug? I can't find any way to get it to move...

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

That really sounds like a but. What wagon did you add? And do you remember the locomotive and tender you choose? Also, send me a pm if the problem stays. I´ll find a way to make you unstuck.

Waylum

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) It's the year 11805 and we're still burning wood for fuel. Or using steam whatever the train runs on. Two way I see it: 1) Recycling DOES make a difference help save the trees. 2) We have enough trees to burn 10k years later!

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

Either that or maybe I´m not using the Christian calendar but another one ^^

Uros

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Wonder if steam tokens will be used for upgrading the level cap or other attributes of the carts maybe? Just level 10 (Or 12 in a few cases) seems quite low.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

There will be a way to raise those caps. But not in all of the wagons since there are reasons for the cap in some cases.

silvadel

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Or once you have fat bertha on coke, you have essentially won the game? And there is no reason to expand beyond 30?

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from Brachiales

Well, right now. But there will be more stuff soon. For now, I work in general improvements but there will be more wagons and locomotives soon.

silvadel

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Is it meant that excess above your cap gets lost as opposed to being spendable at increasing your cap? In essence it means you get a good run then if you want to improve your cap, you have to accept a cruddy train for a couple of runs.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

Yeah, it´s a bit off a bitter pill. I´m not really happy with the current solution neighter. I guess I´l make a nicer formula soon. So you get a better pool and keep some tokens in reserve. U guess I could put this between somehow today. I can´t promise anything right now. But perhaps I can deliver something with today's update. That will be up in a few hours.

silvadel

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I find it kind of annoying that whatever kind of freight car you buy, the value of the freight you are hauling drops to near nothing over time.

+ - !

(0)

atothek

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Would love an option to sell a wagon or start over once you realize you've made a purchase mistake - or even just to scrap lower end wagons to make room for new ones.

+ - !

(0)

dansparrow

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) So, lost all my progress? not planning on starting all over :/ nice concept anyway

+ - !

(1)

silvadel

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I think most people probably thought it was supposed to be 1805 and the 1 was doubled.

+ - !

(1)

NormaTheNorman

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) For example leveling up Coffee Car seems to have no effect at all. Maybe that's a bug though.

+ - !

(0)

NormaTheNorman

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I think it would be nice if levels added to steam token cap. Maybe 1-2 per 10 levels. They system of increasing steam token cap leaves something to be desired. Also many things don't have clear explanations of what they do before you buy them, and sometimes not even after. You may want to go through and add some more explanations here and there, including what leveling up is actually doing, and what are limits. Thanks and thanks for the game.

+ - !

(0)

Kyuss572

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) About ten minutes it I apparently upgraded the carts in such an order to cause a random bug. After clicking the buy upgrade all the text on the screen started vanishing. I clicked the next buy and even more text vanished. I'm now staring at a screen with absolutely no text. All the buttons and other functions still work.

+ - !

(0)

NormaTheNorman

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I love this game.

+ - !

(5)

TerrorTera

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) 118-05, maybe the Trainseries 118 Type 05 as extra :D For this, game need world/permanent steam token upgrade Railway electrification system

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

There is a "big reset" planned around Lvl 10k and more currencies for global upgrades. Electric trains are sadly not planned. All just good old steam. Frankly, I have no idea what this 118-05 means. Google said something about a Turbine powered train. What I did plan at first thought was a power system with a generator cart that makes electricity for some other wagons. But I discarded that concept at least for now.

DukeyT

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) If the train considers weight, drag, etc, then I really feel like you should be able to sell parts that you no longer want or accidentally buy. After unlocking passengers, I decided I wanted a passenger train but had a few freights bringing in little and weighing it down

+ - !

(24)

Developer response from Brachiales

That´s why you can re-build the train already after you bought a few wagons. You lose just your gold and you can already get a better locomotive or tender. And I guess after a few tries you figure out what wagon combos to chose for your play style. Also, wagon upgrades reduce at least the drag. In my opinion, it makes anyway sense to just rebuild quickly a few times in the beginning in order to get your steam token cap up a bit. But perhaps I should have explained that in the game better.

Arctype_

Mar. 25, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) seems alright to me. Different from the other idles which makes me want to play it. Is the date supposed to be the year 11805 though :)

+ - !

(18)

Developer response from Brachiales

I´m surprise it took so long until one asks about the year. There is a reason for the strange number. I prefer to wait a bit for bringing light in the dark there. Since I wonder if someone in the comments figures it out.

TerrorTera

Mar. 24, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) An information of actual progress of steam tokens would be nice. So how do I get them (transport wares, passengers, reach certain kilometers or money)?

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

Yeah, i did not really explain how you obtain the tokens so far. Main reason is that there might be some changes. One source is the amount of wagons your train has (one token per wagon) Another is your amount of Gold, first extra token was for 10k iirc. You get another token after getting many bars/ kilometers. I´m don´t remember how many right now. I will putt in an info panel soon.

TerrorTera

Mar. 24, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Progress was not slow. Get from Lv 0 to Lv 92 in only 1 day. Its an Idle game, this must be slow and run in background. So, don't make game faster. Best earnings are passengers + coffee at beginning

+ - !

(2)

harbingerv1

Mar. 24, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Save feature needed

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

It should save automaticly. If not please tell me your browser and OS.

Brachiales

Mar. 24, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Thanks for playing and rating so far guys. How does the progress feel after the start? Like after 2-3 re-builds. Is it still to slow? If so What´s the main issue? Gold/XP/Steam Tokens? I work right now on a new locomotive that brings a bit better xp/gold boni.

+ - !

(0)

Tenzhi

Mar. 24, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Interesting idea. A bit too slow, I'd say. Car upgrades could coincide with visual improvements. There could also be purchaseable upgrades with benefits for the background objects and possibly the UI. People love upgrades.

+ - !

(39)

Developer response from Brachiales

I can´t give a warranty for visual upgrades right now though it is planned for later. Thing like upgrades that have an influence on background objects and so on will come later. I did not think of GUI things so far but it sounds like a good idea so that goes on the list. Generally, there will be more upgrade later on like global upgrades that influence all wagons of the same type and so on. It´s still more or less a prototype and with just basic functionality. I work on more wagons right now and the balancing of the what is there. More will follow.

Foerby1212

Mar. 24, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Nice idea in general. But its very very slow and I bet you could also make it look nicer. It takes too long to get into and it does not catch a big audience. Thats the resason why yo should make it look nicer, so you get a bigger playerbase. I really like the idea with the night sky btw.

+ - !

(3)

Developer response from Brachiales

I know it´s pretty ugly. However, it´s basicly an alpha state. I will work on the graphics later on at least as far as I´m capable of since I´m a bad drawer. But there will be more background objects and stuff. I also plan to have like levels with different themes. The progress will be a bit faster later on. It´s slow at the beginning in order to introduce new stuff slowly so the player can figure out what the different wagons do. I plan as well to make special wagons with mini games and so on.

TerrorTera

Mar. 23, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) bricks are bugged. 16 lumber and 17 bricks should be sold, but only gain 70 from lumber and 0 from bricks

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from Brachiales

I´ll have a loock at it today. Thanks

Pavels

Mar. 23, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Never mind that comment i figured it out, but maybe you should put something about it in the instructions ?

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Brachiales

Your right. There are many things yet not in the instructions. The reason is that a lot of stuff is not yet written in stone.

Pavels

Mar. 23, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) so if you rebuild you get steam tokens, but what do those tokens do ?

+ - !

(0)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate