Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The main part of this game, aka the item crafting, is soooo interactive. It'd be nice if the battle parts could not be. In other words, I really don't like having to collect the items that fall, or just be screwed out of them.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Decent game but waaaay too long. Got boring after awhile.
I wish you could upgrade how you gather items during battles. Upgrade to a stronger/bigger magnet.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
It's certainly a nice variation of the well-known "Papa's" games. Just 2 things: the shop needs an extension. It pretty much useless except if you need ore. It's frustrating that he has 8 parts maximum in stock and those are never the ones you need.
The other thing is the soldiers. Having the opportunity to chose which you send to battle would be awesome. Thus the epic weapons could be used more efficiently.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
It would be nice if you could spend spare crystals on upgrades like more canon power and faster recharge times or alarm clocks for the ore melts.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I say that cause I had fun at one point making the weapons as bad as I could and it's funny seeing the character's expression when they receive an axe that could hardly be held without injuring the wielder.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I wouldn't mind a sequel, where you booby trap the enemy's army with a poor supply of weapons. The worse and deadlier (for the wearer) you create the weapons the better. 5/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Why doesn't our lovable Jacksmith spend time on making canonballs instead of making weapons? He will get all the credit and make a fortune selling weapon parts and also nobody will get injured, except the monsters maybe :P
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
dont know why mateus is getting downvoted, i spent a lot of time clicking the bookmark button myself. at least a shortcut would be nice.
great game though, 5/5 for this genre so 3/5 for me ;)
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
There should be a bookmark all (and un-bookmark all) button for great weapon parts. When shopping, I often want to know if I have any great weapon designs that use that part.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
As a fan of the Papa's games, I have to say, you guys really came through on this. This is ten times better than the restaurant games. Good job.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Nice game indeed! If I can give a piece of advice, optional equipments could have been categorized by element, and the codes to the items arranged accordingly (e.g. FIR-10, ELE-5...) This way, it helps you both when you are assembling an epic weapon, or only giving some elemental bonus.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Looking at the badges, I thought Dudley would be at the end of the Evershade forest, but since the forest only marks the half-way point of the game, defeating Dudley should definitely be an impossible badge.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Sorry for being such a nerd on this but why if the beast is a water elemental his weakness is water and not fire. Other than that 4/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
it would be best to view whatever you have and told you the states so we don't buy the same thing for one whole weapon that we use the same elements on for each weapon! @slayindp if they order something, the money we earn in the end gets paid to the Jacksmith!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I love it! I'm on lvl 14 and no bugs so far. About improvements: would like to have the role of the monsters and yea, like that. Great game!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
It would be nice to see the epic weapon parts come around more than once. Bookmarking can be confusing if it's for more than one weapon so if you use the wrong part somewhere seems like you never get a shot at that epic weapon again.......the piece never is for sale or dropped after the first time.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I like it except for how much guesswork it takes. Not having a good knowing which ores/parts you'll need to make it through a wave bites. Especially when failing one puts you way behind for other ones.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
the epic weapons should be in a certain order instead of random. most of the epic weapons i got in the later part of the game are useless. copper, bronze etc are pretty useless even if they are epic weapons in the 30 or so days. even when i want to forge them for the same of game completion, i can't unless i want to sacrifice a treasure chest or two.