Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Idle Blacksmith 2

« Back to Idle Blacksmith 2

blaro

May. 01, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) would love the ability to exclude ores and bars from being auto sold. i know with storage protection it will only take enchanted items but during the early game that feature would help alot before you get the enchanter

+ - !

(0)

ken030988

May. 01, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) @Timelessness: As far as i know (heard it from other game's dev), when unity plugin crashes there is a high chance to delete your save file. I heard its a common problem in unity idle games which is why all/most have import/export freature

+ - !

(1)

Timelessness

May. 01, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I've lost my save way too many times. It seems the game lags my computer out until it freezes (after 2-3 days of idling), then my save is lost. Great game besides that.

+ - !

(0)

Ariusz

May. 01, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Overwiev after one month with the game. It's good, fun to play, and the various fixes helped. Still there are many problems. I'm starting to hit the limits here and there (seeling price, training session ascension skill). Gatherers updates are FAR too cheap. as it is now for the price of one blacksmith upgrade I buy 100 or 200 Smelter upgrades whenever he seems to lag behind. All in all some things are still very inbalanced. Well it's still great.

+ - !

(1)

dawndmon

May. 01, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) i'm not getting any offline money XD atleast i get what i would get in 20 secconds of being online...

+ - !

(3)

blackice0823

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Great updates I do have 1 minor complaint after unlocking 5 of the ascend bonuses the 6th goes all the way up to 5.7b that seems really unbalanced I dont remember the 5th being anywhere near that infact all the times I have ascended I havent gotten anywhere near that 5.7b most runs tend to be about 20m. Also a feature I would love to see is maybe a verticle progress bar or 2 on each of the workers for current supply so you can see at a quick glance whats getting low or maybe a timer counting down based on the current gathering how long until the supply is empty. I know it shows in inventory but sometimes the inventory gets very crowded.

+ - !

(2)

emScott

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Wow, nice. A day and a half of offline progress has given me exactly $0 because of the update. :/

+ - !

(4)

Kazeto

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) blaro, it already is there (it's the “Storage Protection” option), it's just that completed items are ones that are enchanted too so it'll be quite some time before you can actually finish items.

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) They mention it earlier but I want to give an example again :) With the update (nearly 2 weeks ago) upgrades became useless after specific levels. For ex for workers production speed after lvl 800. Now I am Level 1562 and giving more than 10.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000$ and i am earning less than 0.01 second faster blacksmith production. It doesn't make sense. Is there a barrier for speed or something ?

+ - !

(0)

Hauke

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) This is a nice follow-up to Idle Blacksmith with much potential. Thank you for your invested time! A few ideas: 1) Someone mentioned in an earlier post they'd like to see the ability to transfer items from the Shop back to Inventory. (Only re-iterated that because I don't see it on the Most Recent Posts and it was up-voted on my part) 2) Scrolling between items (For example: The Explorer's "Cat's eye" to "Bloodstone", etc...) becomes tedious after a while. Would it be possible to implement a drop-down list, with scroll-bar, on the item's text box? And finally 3) Unless I missed something, the shop owner always sells the most expensive first. Could you add a "sell priority" setting with "Most expensive", "Least expensive" and finally, for the O.C.D. group: "Least quantity". Again, Thank you for a great idle game! Cheers! -Hauke

+ - !

(3)

kingpin01

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Potions seem pretty useless. They sell for less than the materials used to create them, and they only last for 30s early on. Why would i ever create potions? Some of the listed values are wrong too. Poor Golden Potion says it's base value is 2.1B, but it sells for 43M x4 =$175M

+ - !

(-1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Later you will be able to make potions that can last up to 6 hours :)

blaro

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) i might be missing something but is their an option for the merchant to only auto take the finished items from the smith and not the ores and bars?

+ - !

(1)

ReFro

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) The druid and enchanter resource reduction seems to not take normal upgrades into effect, but it does take your SP upgrades into effect. I current have 20% reduction from SP upgrades and 46% from normal upgrades, but the display is showing a flat 20% for both workers and the number of items it takes to produce something is rather high (80 items to make an exceptional golden potion) for a supposedly ~66% reduction.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

It's because normal upgrade only apply to ingredient or treasure. They are shown under the herbalist and explorer info window.

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) And I want to mention new potion icon near to the progress bar. I like that :) I can see is it finish or near to finish :)

+ - !

(0)

krzwis

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) thanks for posting that Chrome unity fix, btw. you not only made all my games run again but as a side effect I can check my work scheduled online again :P

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) If you are still working on potion system. "Drink last potion again for all" will be better. And I dont like new potion system auto potion is 10 times shorter and doesnt work offline. What is the point ? It is useless for me if it doesnt work offline and Why i will make it auto it is just for 10 times shorter ? I have investment on potions and my new potions are 8 hours long. I need to check them 4-5 times a day. Thats all. But potion system wasnt working properly last days. I hope everything will be fine soon :)

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for your comment. The potion system has been fixed.

rmhermen

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Enchanter needs to work offline!

+ - !

(3)

Keilian

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) the 'rate' of the merchant seems very... off balance... trying to do 'very low price'.. and taking minutes to sell 1 thing.. yet i've got like 160 ranks to make him 'better'...

+ - !

(1)

Rhazaak

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Any plans to allow the merchant to sell the cheapest items first?

+ - !

(1)

gamblerselite

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) auto drinking potions leads to infinite potion time aka negitive time

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Refresh the game to fix the problem.

Kurst

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) after auto poition upgrade: Poitions dont work over all. they get substracted but no buff occurs nor the duration of the poiton drops over time. it is just frozen. pls fix fast.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

It has been fixed.

bmyxb

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) The potion time stop counting, weird.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Fixed now!

kzaznsojr

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) The production times between items is not equal. Left the game for 24 hours with production from the "Blacksmith" at 0.11/s and "Enchanter" at 0.12/s. Logically there should be no spare armor when I come back but had about 4000 pieces lying around waiting to be enchanted

+ - !

(4)

blake62

Apr. 30, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) the "crit" display effect has disappeared. Is it normal?

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for the report. It's fixed now.

psycomata

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) you get the effect of the potions but the timer never starts so u dont get counted for the achievement or anything

+ - !

(5)

mistermoray

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) So, I was working on a stockpile to keep cash flowing while working on quests and had about 1100 items in the shop. I went offline for a few hours and came back to find 1000 unenchanted items in storage and nothing in the shop. I got my offline earnings, but what a setback. It seems that the enchanter didn't do a thing offline. It's happened before in smaller amounts, but I just thought it was my enchanter falling behind. Since then I've made sure my enchanter was always faster than my blacksmith to try and keep something like this from happening. That enchanter be lazy.

+ - !

(3)

doomsdaydevice

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Can you put in a feature to take items out of the shop and back into your inventory?

+ - !

(4)

Ardagan

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Potion time never ends now.

+ - !

(17)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for the report. The bug has been fixed now.

Ardagan

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Auto potions don't seem to work. It also doesn't state what type of potion will worker consume (I have like 10 different feasible ones).

+ - !

(3)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for your comment. It will be fixed soon.

Fabian1657

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I like it that you communicate with your players! It shows that you are motivated and dedicated to make it as good as possible for us! thank you!! hope to have a nice chat one day :P :)

+ - !

(0)

Fabian1657

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) nice update, only I have the problem that the duration of my potions doesn't go down, it stays at 30s. for the speed potion and doesn't descent

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for the report. It will fixed soon. In the meanwhile. That's free potion effect for everybody!!!

Alvarenga

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) At what lvl is the enchanter unlocked?

+ - !

(0)

Kazeto

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) 300 SP is a nice value for the first one, dennan01, assuming you get something sensible like “Inflation” or “Fast Production”, rather than the very first skill (“Rich Starter”). I don't quite remember what the cost of the second skill was, but you have enough to upgrade either of those I'd mentioned enough to make your progress noticeably faster.

+ - !

(0)

dennan01

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) When should you do your first accension ? For best value so to speak. I am currently at 300 SP.

+ - !

(1)

daudle

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Yeah, enchanting still doesn't work right offline. I know someone else has mentioned this one. I know you have got a lot of requests, and you are a great dev who actually talks to people on here. I don't expect this to be fixed today and not mad about it. I just thought I would make the comment to help you out.

+ - !

(1)

Edenwrath

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I enjoy this game a lot, it's well thought and well programmed... As far as idle game goes, this is one of the best cause, even if it's sill an idle game, i have to make some decisions and tweak things here and there. There is just one tiny little suggestion i'd like to make (well, two actually), one cosmetic and one gameplay related. First : Knowing the price of items your merchant is selling would be nice (i mean the one she's actually in the process of selling). Second : While "Storage protection" is a nice feature, it would really be cool if you could set it for some workers and not others. On a related note, that could be a way for the merchand to take potions you don't want to keep from storage... :)

+ - !

(0)

stonedwarf

Apr. 29, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) i logged in to find that i only made 136m$ after some time away. I am regularly making molybdenite mail at .18/min and enchanting with the eagle at .13/min and selling at expensive price at .13/min. Offline mode should reflect this but its not. Instead it just assumed I was continuing to sell my potions which gave me 336$ per second. I should be making a lot more even in offlne. Please fix this.

+ - !

(2)

osirisone

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) the offline gain system is buggy ... im closed the tap and the next morning has nothing gained - great game anywere 5*

+ - !

(2)

ken030988

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) @tajg0: Chrome doesnt support unity plugin. Its not the game's developer fault, complain to google (since chrome belongs to them) and/or Unity Technologies.

+ - !

(3)

tajg0

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-12)

urbanautters

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) foxes26 maybe your browser reset your history, including all cached items. either you did it not knowing it would reset flash/unity games or it is set to automatically do it every once in a while!

+ - !

(0)

Foxes26

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Whoa, whoa. I just logged in and my entire game has been reset, I'm back at the beginning. What the hell?

+ - !

(3)

omargonzalez233

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) The potion base values shown in the druid window are wrong. The actual value is much much lower and you only see that after you made the potion and sell it. Please fix.

+ - !

(3)

blake62

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I don't know if I'm doing something wrong, but I find the progression the game is very slow. It makes days I'm in the quadrillion range, 3000 SP are waiting and it increase so slowly. Upgrades cost Qds and have almost no impact. I can't imagine to wait 5802 points to unlock new capabilities.

+ - !

(1)

seekill

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Awesome thanks durpish.

+ - !

(0)

Durpish

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) @seekill when you ascend u keep the enchanter

+ - !

(0)

seekill

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I really appreciate any feedback on when I should ascend, I started playing today and I got to my sacrifice count on reset number up to about 2k but it seems like the skills you buy with them aren't good enough to warrant all the slow pre-enchanter progress I would have to go through again.

+ - !

(0)

Durpish

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) is "a really big scam" the final merchant option??

+ - !

(0)

seekill

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) How many sacrifice points should you have before first respec?

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 28, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Now all of my titles became lvl10. There is not much to do :)

+ - !

(0)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate