Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Idle Blacksmith 2

« Back to Idle Blacksmith 2

Wraith_78

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I like how the chest of infinite money has a specific price.

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Hehe :)

Ardagan

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-3)

doodiiidoo

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) 30 second potions, i never use them.

+ - !

(5)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for your comment. I'll keep it in mind in the next potions update.

xandramas

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Alright, a couple of weeks and a few resets and still feels like im playing it for the first run. The progress in this game is way too slow. I MAY be back in a few weeks to see if its any better.

+ - !

(0)

ellsieelle

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) can someone help me with how to unlock the enchanter?

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) There is too much items but you can go easily high and you are getting to top easy. And you dont even understand you get to top. And at top you cant produce items fast or earn much. I think you need to make a balance by items power needed. For ex : If Top1 ore (infinitium) needs 8B, Top2 ore (pionyxium) has to be 5 or 6B most, But it is 7,411B. and top3 ore needs to be 3-4 B. And yes upgrades costs reduced but their effect become useless. I cant even feel the difference between Lvl600 and LvL1200 workers.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for your comment.

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) With last updates it is to easy to get middle of the game but it is too hard to get to the top. When you are top it is useless to being on top and boring. And there is not much different of being on top or building top items. There is lack of a balance. People says that too frequently but i think giving specific examples will make it clear. For ex: Now I am producing the top1 ore(infinitium in 5.2 per minute). But other items there is not much difference. If I want to produce 10 per second. I need to back to mid-level ore (Exatinium).

+ - !

(0)

xaviersxmen

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) AND yet again I come back after bed with no off line makings. That NEEDS to be fixed. I lost out on alot of money and Ascend points.

+ - !

(0)

NamelessMinion

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Any way you could lower the cost of the first level of enchanting power? It's really bottle-necking the beginning of each ascension.

+ - !

(2)

Vaserati

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Just so you know, in the Big Upgrade Window, after the second patch the mining icon changed to the blacksmithing icon.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

What have I done!!! It will be fixed in the next version. Thannk you for the report.

leboss34

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) afk mode is a GREAT idea :D

+ - !

(0)

KingofFame

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) please add a drink(all) option for potions so we dont have to click 8 times/scroll to apply a potion to each homeboy.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for your suggestion.

Sleepingpill

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) So, was away from the game for some time, and now most of my ascencion skills costs 5802 sp, except for nimble hand (which cost 65) and perfectionist (which cost 326), whats up with that?

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Ascension skills need to be unlocked before you can upgrade them normaly. Unlock cost increase with each skill you unlock. Upgrade cost is specific for each skill.

Animato

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Ingredient efficiency and treasure efficiency don't seem to work: I had them at 0 and quickly bought them both to 70, but I see no change in the amount of resources needed by the druid and the enchanter. I have also noticed the reduction % is shown in the herbalist and explorer tooltips, not in the druid and enchanter ones as it should be.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Herbalist and Explorer resource reduction is written in their tooltips because it only apply to their resources. Druid and Enchanter resource reduction written in thier tooltips are applied both resources they need.

xwintx

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Should have protection function for specific resource not all resource in storage.

+ - !

(0)

Comett

Apr. 23, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) When i export/import from home to work over night, it didnt make any progress at all. Is it intended ?

+ - !

(2)

blackice0823

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I wish units would be the same I hate when it changes from units per second to minute also I would love a function to be able to turn inventory protection off for some types but not all. Say my enchanter/smith/druid(non +1 and better) items can be grabbed and sold but not my herbalist/explorer/miner/smelter

+ - !

(3)

xandramas

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) This game isnt enchanting while its closed

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I didnt saw the last update. The game was so boring with the update before. Now it has a sense to play but still bugs and things to do. I hope you will continue to read our comments and develop your game. The next buggy one is enchanting items. You cant choose the item you want to enchant for example i want(Or I need for quest) to enchant 100 zetalium helm but I have 100 infinitium mail, 50 pionyxium sword, 200 omicrine helm , 40 xirite mail, 70 nurium boots, 80 murium mail (You can think it is exaggeration but my situation is much much worse) I need to get rid of all then start enchanting weapon. And next quest i need them again and i start enchant again. In short, enchanting is really pain in the ass especially when we start producing, selling so slow :) The next one in my priority is potions. If you drink a potion by mistake you cant use the other one without older ones effect finish. We need to drink the new one whenever we want.

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for your comment. I'm glad you enjoyed the last update. Thanks for the report on the enchanter. I will take care of it. For the potions, i'm happy to announce that the feature you asks is already in the game (i've added it a few days ago). Just click on the progress bar of the potions. It will cancel it instantly.

Foxes26

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I don't seem to be getting any more offline gains, what's going on?

+ - !

(0)

TugaKnight

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Could we have an option to auto consume potions?

+ - !

(2)

white_exodus

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-3)

LordTokyo

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) It would be neat if you could click the quest materials in red and have a button that assigns all workers to produce/find the materials in question, rather than shuffle through all the items and set them manually

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

In the quest window. Click the requirement. It will set it automatically :)

RedeemedWahrior

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Productivity upgrade does not seem to increase the merchant's work power.

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Anyway I am done with Idle Blacksmith. It was nice game :)

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

I'm glad you enjoyed it.

Samarkand100

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I think the enchanter stops working when you're offline. He processes equipment faster than my blacksmith makes it, but I always come back to huge surpluses.

+ - !

(0)

wolf55

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) My save got deleted. Kinda pissed. Done with idle games for a bit.

+ - !

(0)

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I want to give a short & simple example, I hope it will be enough to explain how it ruins our fun. "Before update, I earn money for upgrades in minutes. After update, I cant earn that money in a day. I can earn it like 1 year later." And if it continues like that I have no reason to play that game anymore. I think others will think the same.

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for your comment. A new balance update has just been released.

atilimsasmaz

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I am agree with Vertal. Last update really ruin game. I hope you will finish next update soon.

+ - !

(1)

Vertal

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) You really messed up the late game balance, getting anywhere takes far too long now. It used to be just fine; why are you trying to ruin your own game?

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

The end of the game was messed up. The balance update was to address that issue. Ascension skills cap have been raised for 4 skills. Fast production effect have been doubled. Upgrade Cost have been lowered (mid game). More are going to come (including auto-potions). My goal is not to ruin my own game don't worry. My goal is to make "non-upgrade" feature more important. Ascension skills, potions and titles should be more important to the game. You can expect more effect from those in the near future.

white_exodus

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) everything works when i closed the browser but enchanter and seller don't work :( when i open the game afte a few hours the storage is full with unenchanted equip and i have no more money than before

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for the report.

Socky

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) And I don't understand the new late game balance. I had to go down at least 10 tiers of metal at my current stats, so I make nowhere near enough to level anything up.

+ - !

(6)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for you comment. I'll keep it in mind in the next update.

Socky

Apr. 22, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) The bonus selling money you get from SP should be a percentage rather than a fixed amount. Otherwise it's just useless..

+ - !

(13)

Keiran87

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Another suggestion. I think this game deserves a forum. I tried to work my spreadsheet to calculate the optimal lvling strategy and optimal items to craft/enchant to maximize the money gain but there is too many data to collect - some things are quite obvious other require some more naalysis with larger datasamples which i am to slow to collect on my own. If we could crowsource it together it would bu muuch more enjoyable to me. I understand that figuring it out on our own might be part of the competition but, to me it is more important to do as good as it is possible than to better than other players. What do you think?

+ - !

(3)

LittleKimmy

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Fix your import save window it cant even take all the save code it stops likeafter 200 characters and I have thousands

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for the report. You can send me a private message with your export file and i'll fix it for you.

LittleKimmy

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Be sure you copied every character bla bla bla Like I typed in character after character... I copied my export file And when I export it not working.......!!!!

+ - !

(2)

LittleKimmy

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Even exporting the game the save doesnt work.... I lost my game a third time it sucks

+ - !

(0)

Miscellaneous

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Possible bug re the enchanting and quest systems - if I move an un-enchanted item into the store, when the stack is sold it happens to the whole stack, I get no money, and the quest marker goes up despite the item being un-enchanted (ie make 56 Kunzite gloves of fire - put a stack of 10 Kunzite gloves in the store and they make the counter go from 0/56 to 10/56)

+ - !

(0)

NightMunky

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I would love to be able to set the number of decimal points for production rate.

+ - !

(0)

aethirshero

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) I'm glad that this game is under constant updating, but it really slows me down to suddenly find that I need different ingredients to make things, or that it's gonna take hours to make what took minutes before. Hehe, keep them coming though. I'd rather have an awesome game than an awesome run in one. ;P

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

I'm glad you enjoy the game. Enchanter and Druid recipe shouldn't change anymore.

kzaznsojr

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Anyone else with unity problems?

+ - !

(5)

Developer response from mrcaboom

See Instructions for a fix to make unity work again with Chrome.

RedeemedWahrior

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Why does Critical Party not affect my merchant? Is he not one of my workers? :(

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thanks for the report.

Deadeye00

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) The quest text (red?) is hard to read.

+ - !

(-1)

ssjdynasty

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) great game but please add more levels or new powerups to spend our billions of worthless ascension points. thanks

+ - !

(1)

Developer response from mrcaboom

The new update raised the cap of 4 ascension skills.

Shinis1

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Got a maxed Blacksmith (2000) and was able to produce the 3rd highest mail (Xirite, Nr 77 of 80) at a 10/s rate. Now thats the case for the 20th (Stibnite) oO that might be an a bit too harsh decrease. Well lets ascend I guess, got 4.1 Tr SP to spent haha.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Congratulations!

Rawrkanos

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) Mate, you ruined this game.

+ - !

(0)

Rawrkanos

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) F*ck these changes. I had to drop my ore-mining by something like 20 levels because of this crap "balance" changes.

+ - !

(3)

kaijick

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) OK I have been playing this for quite a few days now and I have come to the conclusion the game is too slow to be worth investing more time. It takes FOREVER to earn enough money to upgrade, let alone the fact that the upgrades offer MINIMAL increases each time. Ascending is useless with the bonuses that are offered. Had a lot of potential but until the game speed is increased significantly, I am lowering my rating to 2 stars due to the fact the game is alive and well made but impossible to really play. I let it idle for 12 hours just now and came back to a whole whopping 10 upgrade points worth of money, split amongst all of my jobs, so it wasn't like I was just upgrading the highest level stuff I had. Also noted the patch notes today say the game was MADE EVEN SLOWER. Sorry about this one guys =(

+ - !

(2)

Developer response from mrcaboom

Thank you for your comment. There was a bug in the game (Once you reach a certain point around 1.5k work power upgrade on a worker) that make you able to complete everything quite quickly). That speed reduction have been applied to those people. (Some people were able to get 10B+ SP in 4 days). Ascensions skills cap have been doubled. Fast Production effect have been double. Upgrade cost have been lowered. Merchant now sells faster. So in fact, for most people, the game is faster.

YankeePhoneGuy

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) slower? oh well it was fun.

+ - !

(1)

hiyadare3

Apr. 21, 2015

Under rating threshold (show) the description says You will mine ores. You will smelt them into metal bars. You will forge them into equipment. You will enchant your equipment. You will sell them and become rich. You will complete quest for the king. You will gather rare ingredients from the forest. You will explore the world for valuable treasure. You will brew powerful potions. You will achieve tedious task. You will ascend into the next generation of blacksmith. Can you manage your business to become the most notorious blacksmith of all time? YAH! MABEY IN 10 YEARS

+ - !

(-1)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate