Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Idle Blacksmith

« Back to Idle Blacksmith

almera77

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Need more upgrades please :) Really like the game btw m8, good job.

+ - !

(1)

Blargsson

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Offline mode does not seem to be working. I had my progress wiped when reentering the game.

+ - !

(0)

rrrrex

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Could you show price of 10, while holding ctrl?

+ - !

(0)

Xeneonic

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) @metaldom The dev confirmed that critically selling a "Very Expensive" item would sell it for double.

+ - !

(2)

metaldom

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Two things. Some kind of critical notification would make it feel better. What happens when you critically sell on "Very Expensive"?

+ - !

(2)

xandramas

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) The game is fun but you get to a point where the upgrades seem to have no effect. I just spent about 5P on enchant and it didnt even noticeably go any faster on an average speed enchantment.

+ - !

(0)

polyglot

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Thank you for implementing the sell progress, clicks per sell and the like. I realized I had been playing it wrong, the very cheap sells make the most money, as long as you have a production chain to keep up. I had been trying to get my production chain slow enough to keep my 'very expensive' priced sales with no downtime. my bad.

+ - !

(0)

blants

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) the autism unfolds update by glorious update

+ - !

(-2)

Roku1234

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) @1benjy1 Sorry, but the problem you are having isn't connected to a local storage. Unity uses a different storage setting than Flash, so it's either your browser isn't saving it correctly, or the version of Unity is corrupt in some way.

+ - !

(0)

UserError

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) I dub thee "Idle Blacksmith: Destroyer of Mice"

+ - !

(1)

thacannon

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) You know, a nice yellow glow to the progress bar whenever you hit a critical-whatever would be nice too.

+ - !

(4)

1benjy1

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Rating changed to 1/5 and will stay that way till game saves to local storage automatically and I get my data lol DX

+ - !

(-2)

1benjy1

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) That moment when you close the window and then all your progress is gone. real cool :/

+ - !

(-2)

rhekis

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) any chance you could add the number of bars required for smelting and forging steps? Really enjoying the challenge to optimize, fun game :)

+ - !

(0)

manticore912

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Perhaps you could implement the ability to enchant low grade items as well or maybe have a bulk sell option for large quantities of items, like you do with ores but with forged items.

+ - !

(0)

ace_case

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) When buying in multiples, there should be a away to see how many you are getting, and how much it's going to cost you while you hold control or shift.

+ - !

(0)

dragonelli

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) having trouble with import/export as no text data is being generated. tried in both normal and cinematic modes. using goolge chrome running on windows 7 home premium 64

+ - !

(0)

Rawrsaur

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) I notice once an item starts to be enchanted or sold it can't be traded for something else. I would like to see these items be put to the top of the inventory in yellow font or something and be clickable with the option to "stop current work" or something of the sort. Also being able to mark items in inventory as "next to sell" regardless of position and value.

+ - !

(-1)

Ardagan

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) How about adding a log of sales?

+ - !

(0)

Zarthos

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-10)

xDeathVoidx

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) I feel there is the need to have a toggle auto mode. I mean, I'm trying to move onto a better tier of items but it automakes a lot of something before I even have the chance to click the next arrow.

+ - !

(4)

cosmos5000

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) OH GOD not another idle game... this one is kinda good

+ - !

(1)

Barkalot

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) how long of a period is the MPS calculated over? Also I would LOVE a way to reset the MPS.

+ - !

(0)

thacannon

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) The Auto Mine upgrade needs reworking I think. For a component that is required to be 3+ times faster than the next component, it should provide more power than it does now. I currently have 119 Auto Smelt costing pennies, yet a 185 Auto Mine (that doesn't even satisfy the smelting process btw), costing me some of my limbs. And with the cost increasing exponentially, I can't imagine how end game works at that rate. Meh Ima sleep over it and see how ascension turns out. Otherwise, it's a fun idle so far that I actually don't want to use an auto-clicker on it.

+ - !

(4)

zovjraar

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) LOVE the new inventory control & selling bars!! thank you!

+ - !

(0)

JamesC25

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) @Tryko That's odd, for me the auto forge is most expensive. Maybe it differs per person?

+ - !

(0)

joelama102

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-3)

lozmaster1991

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) when you ascend you should keep your achievements instead of losing them

+ - !

(5)

s375

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) When Importing, ascending, hard resetting and such there needs to be a "Confirm" action pop up before going through with it. Accidentally imported when trying to export and lost several hours of progress :& 5/5 for game tho, pretty gun

+ - !

(2)

Killstead

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Love where this is going. One of the better idles out there. Looking forward to more future updates. 5/5

+ - !

(1)

Ardagan

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-5)

NyanchuStudios

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) To the people who are saying they lost their progress, this is why there is a backup option!

+ - !

(2)

Steven_90

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) "Crit Selling" even on "Very expensive" increases the average value multiplier when upgraded, so it much be doing something, hope this helps :)

+ - !

(2)

absroker3

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-6)

UhmIWin

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Yo tigerstar, it's a game, not a dictionary.

+ - !

(0)

thelomeliway

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-4)

carigun95

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) i find selling the objects slow, i now the selling would always be slower but not that slower. and the upgrades are expensive

+ - !

(0)

Foniko_rapanaki

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Just a Tip on the Formula you guys should follow for max profit: lets say i mine 1 Columbite ore every 3 sec, i make 3sec * 3 (one bar) witch is 9, if my smelter is at or less than 9 sec then it it is all good, now lets say i make columbite armour withc needs 9 bars, now i will calculate those 9 secs (each bar) * 9 witch is 81, so now if my forge, enchanter and seller are less than 81 seconds i am doing good or i should upgrade them, if they are too fast then i should move up to the next ore. Now you should know what needs upgrading and when you should move to the next ore. Cheers!

+ - !

(3)

lozmaster1991

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) i lost all of my progress and i did not reset my game

+ - !

(4)

wizard2002

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) it doesnt work D:

+ - !

(1)

godisawesome

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-16)

joshsol

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) too slow of progression, and not enough 'reward'. to keep me interested beyond Trillions... (and barely even before that)

+ - !

(-2)

loligager101

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) If you have a Touch Screen laptop Like mine YOUR FINGERS WILL START TO HURT (Basically I'm saying it a great game....... to break your fingers with)

+ - !

(-2)

atgc

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) I can somehow understand why people would be bothered by such a thing as "steel ore". Steel has highly varying degrees of quality, and there's a bazillion ways to make it, and I gather this isn't steelmaking simulator 2014. I can't really make any suggestions unless the game decides to stop idling (d'ohohoh) at the "IDLE BLACKSMITH" screen, but making steel from iron does make sense.

+ - !

(-1)

Rafael64

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Idle blacksmith upgrading stuff for idle miner and drinking lemonade from idle capitalist when idle.

+ - !

(0)

zay31

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) "Hurrr steel ore doesn't exist" Get over it. It's a game, some of the ores besides that don't exist..

+ - !

(-1)

Wormeh

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Are critical selling and critical magic still useful when you are at the largest selling point (Very expensive) and/or enchantment point? If not, then they are useless late game :)

+ - !

(3)

Mckaime

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) Would be cool if there was a tooltip or a hover-over option to see what your net gain/loss per resource is per minute. I try to balance everything out when I go idle, but if I could see +5 ore/minute or -1 ore/minute, that would help a lot. good stuff

+ - !

(4)

syr1

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) The developer should add "idiotonium ore" so all the people whining about steel ore can complain that idiotonium isn't real, seeing as playing this game as made them all real life blacksmith apprentices and smithing is serious business. Next story: Minecrafters unionize and demand pay.

+ - !

(12)

Infiltratores

Sep. 03, 2014

Under rating threshold (show) i have 58.81G accension levels but get -2.147.483.648 score for highscore

+ - !

(3)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate