Under rating threshold (hideshow)
it sucks how you get the best units first because there's nothing to buy except equipment. and i also liked the previous games unit leveling up system. also i hate it when there's all ground creatures except for one flying unit. anyway other than these things its a great game 5/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
3 stars, it's a well-done game but in its current form I'm not sure I'd even call it half-finished.
I like having lots of units. It looks like there's 60+. Good thing I've got a Protectopedia to tell me about them, right? Well, it doesn't; it just gives me some lore that's nice but not helpful. The first thing I learned: melee units can't damage flying enemies. This would be fine, except the game's leveling system seems to encourage you to power-level one or two heroes and ignore the rest. So heroes with melee units are useless. You can swap units randomly, but there's no way to tell what units you can get except experience. Many units have buffs so similar they can be considered identical.
Maybe I'd know this stuff if I'd played Protector I-III, but that's not a good excuse. To me, it feels like the creator should have let this one sit on the drawing board for another couple of months and added some documentation. A big game requires explanation; this game lacks it.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Just repeat "The Great Hydra" for endless Exp =)
Good for those players that need extra help with the levels on the heroes. =)
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Great game!
Just two things I'm unclear on-- what hits flying enemies, and which icons corralate to which elements? I'm pretty sure I know the answers to each, but I don't want to risk making a big mistake...
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I'm not really sure that items that increase steal chance actually do anything, even when equipped to cutpurse and gentleman.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I disagree, arch wizards and regular wizards that hit a large area are perfect when they can poison the enemy for large ammounts of damage 1 or two of them can pretty much take out whole waves when they reach max posion level. They also level up even faster then others since they do hit a larger area allowing them to do more damage then anything else.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
- cool game but it needs rock/paper/scissors in every quest, it seems that now when chosing fire hero you don't have to worry about anything. We still have 3 heroes for every quest so why not making quests requiring more than one element? Yes, there are a few quests that require 2 elements but you get my point.
- it's impossible to buy an advanced unit at the beginning of the quest even if you have enough money (Logistics 25+), my idea was to buy pala as the first unit, is it supposed to be so?
- xbow is still overpowered, no other units are needed. Why do we have so many units then?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I wish the storyline were longer! longer mini campaigns for each guild would be awesome (storyline is always cool =P).
That way finishing the game would be longer and longer =)
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
@Pieface2 :
as far as I remember from Protector 3, Consecration lessens the effect of the enemy's Strength; ie. if your unit has Fire element, and the enemy's strength is Fire, then your unit will have less damage penalty to it with consecration.
hope i remember right
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
i was thinking it would be good to be able to look at what all the bonuses you got from talents are combined on one screen
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
All the heros that you can recruit are garbage, but I guess that is ok because I started with an energy, physical, and fire and recruited another fire at the beginning. I then used the new fire and the other two to beat everything. Never needed poison nor cold, flaw?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I'm having some serious problems with the game loading. One hour it loads fine, but then it just black screens another. No idea why, any thoughts what it could be?
Yes I have the newest flash player.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Fire+Melee+Range+Elemental Switching=OWNAGE; hardly used the other factions (Arkadia was more than enough for me) and I had near zero need for magicians as they were only useful at the beginning of the game. Hmmm...maybe I'll make another file where I focus of mages or other factions although I would probably still focus on fire...it seems to be the best element out there. Any thoughts or tips about that?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
A wonderful game, and the best Protector to date in my opinion. If there's anything I could suggest to make this better, it would be to expand the Protectopedia to include more details on gameplay mechanics: such as descriptions of special abilities, and even the basic stats of units. I still don't even know exactly what most of the abilities do, just what I can guess using common sense. Overall, though, a great game, and deserves my 5-star rating and favorite. Keep up the great games!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
best advanced units:
Huscarl (melee): can skill for a lot of additional damage (i think 8 times +30-50%)
Crossbow (as you may think: ranged): can skill for +xxx% damage to flying units
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
overall great game but I miss the challenge of your previous versions. None of the levels were hard at all. You have a lot of content but I found that I never had to use any of it. After about 4 missions I added scrolls to the first three heroes i had and then only changed when I needed to change element. Never got more than three heroes and really only used one of them. Previous versions you had to think very carefully about which units you were going to use and where to place them. Here just pick one ranged and mass produce. Still enjoyed but on the next one go back to the basics and make it hard again. Thanks for your efforts.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I wish it had been more clear that the Stores are only for selling an item. I accidentally sold my first skill scroll because I thought that's how you were supposed to "use" it. No way to reverse the transaction, either. Very weak. I also don't like that the quests vanish if you fail them. I would prefer to be able to work on my tactics, and hammer away at the quests until I beat them. That's how strategy games are supposed to work.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
When you mouse over 5/5, it says "lovED it". Everyone who beats these games says, "There's nothing left to do", and then rates it lower. Many games on this site deserve higher ratings but don't get them for this reason and I think it needs to stop.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
ok a little Plus sign for the "Im Getting Bored button" XD 5/5 great game love the dept love the game play love the little things that are amusing lol great game and thanks for staying on Kongregate n not those other sites!!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
@boogeyratt: look at the enemy preview, it will suggest a unit type to you. (Hint: it's almost always "ranged or magic (there's no difference).")