Isn't this game illegal? (locked)

Subscribe to Isn't this game illegal? 47 posts

Sign in to reply


 
avatar for rawismojo rawismojo 6091 posts
Flag Post

Gameplay can’t be copyrighted. The graphics are similar, but not identical by any means, so that doesn’t infringe either. Therefore, this game is just fine.

 
avatar for Mureth Mureth 441 posts
Flag Post

If it’s like Advance Wars, then It’s Final Fantasy Tactics Advanced which means it’s like that game which i think was called, Orcs and some free online game…

 
avatar for 2640ICSx 2640ICSx 1185 posts
Flag Post

what? are you kidding me? illegal? lolololololololololololololololololololololol i can’t handle the funniness of this

 
avatar for ShadowMog ShadowMog 126 posts
Flag Post

The funny thing is this is his ONLY post. Ever.

 
avatar for kaboom4me kaboom4me 47 posts
Flag Post

Epic fail

 
avatar for piratemonkey piratemonkey 4542 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by joppelarius:

But I still believe Nintendo would win if they sued Batallion’s creator. The graphics look almost the same as well rawismojo.

If they did then INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS would get most the money anyway.
And they wouldn’t win.

And you do FAILZ.

 
avatar for piratemonkey piratemonkey 4542 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by joppelarius:

And you do FAILZ.

Whatever. Why don’t you try spelling your verb forms correctly in stead of attempting to lolspeak. ’Cause in that language YOU fail. Epic fail. -

FAILZ

 
avatar for ShadowMog ShadowMog 126 posts
Flag Post

joppelarius, are you, perhaps, an IP/copyright lawyer? Any case studies you could point to? No? Stop trying to be an internet vigilante.

BTW, infringing copyright isn’t an illegal offense. You can’t get jailed for stealing someone else’s work and claiming it as your own, just sued/ostracized, so no, it’s not illegal, even if you could be sued and the case could be somehow won.

Before you ask, jail time received from infringing copyright usually arises because they have to circumvent some form of copyright protection (i.e. DRM protected code) or breaking into a secure facility/workstation (which is also a crime). Although monetizing MIGHT cause some legal trouble…

Anyway, this game is similar enough that it’s possible, but very unlikely, that they would be sued for copyright misappropriation. It’s doubtful though, because there’s also that iPhone “Advanced Wars” copy that’s been around from a while already called Mecho Wars…

 
avatar for rawismojo rawismojo 6091 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by joppelarius:

But I still believe Nintendo would win if they sued Batallion’s creator. The graphics look almost the same as well rawismojo.

You didn’t even read my post. There are legal decisions supporting the fact that you can’t copyright gameplay.

 
avatar for Conquerer95 Conquerer95 2815 posts
Flag Post

It is obviously not illegal and obviously will not be banned because the testing for this has been going on for about 3 months. Although it is similar to advanced wars, it is not completley the same.

 
avatar for sportsmaster19 sportsmaster19 4562 posts
Flag Post

as long as it isn’t the same game (graphics, SYSTEM!) it isn’t a copywrite…

 
avatar for ShadowMog ShadowMog 126 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by Conquerer95:

It is obviously not illegal and obviously will not be banned because the testing for this has been going on for about 3 months. Although it is similar to advanced wars, it is not completley the same.

Actually the game has been around for years in various incarnations…

 
avatar for commie_commander commie_comma... 10454 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by ShadowMog:
Originally posted by Conquerer95:

It is obviously not illegal and obviously will not be banned because the testing for this has been going on for about 3 months. Although it is similar to advanced wars, it is not completley the same.

Actually the game has been around for years in various incarnations…

i can even name 2!

 
avatar for james123193 james123193 1435 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by commie_commander:
Originally posted by ShadowMog:
Originally posted by Conquerer95:

It is obviously not illegal and obviously will not be banned because the testing for this has been going on for about 3 months. Although it is similar to advanced wars, it is not completley the same.

Actually the game has been around for years in various incarnations…

i can even name 2!

well i don’t care.

 
avatar for Babadingldoo Babadingldoo 4298 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by james123193:
Originally posted by commie_commander:
Originally posted by ShadowMog:
Originally posted by Conquerer95:

It is obviously not illegal and obviously will not be banned because the testing for this has been going on for about 3 months. Although it is similar to advanced wars, it is not completley the same.

Actually the game has been around for years in various incarnations…

i can even name 2!

well i don’t care.

well no one cares that you don’t care, so stop telling us.

 
avatar for jacobdf12 jacobdf12 705 posts
Flag Post

This is the stupidest argument I’ve heard(or,um read) If it was illegal it would’ve been taken off by now no offense to anyone, but THINK A LITTLE

 
avatar for amanofnotalent amanofnotalent 7 posts
Flag Post

hey the game was made to be fun, just because it looks like some other game doesn’t mean that it’s been stolen. like most games nowadays they all look the same kinda but are completely different!

 
avatar for Panzershrek44 Panzershrek44 264 posts
Flag Post

It is realated to Advance wars but it cant be deleted.This game is VERY legal.Under stood people?

 
avatar for Jon509 Jon509 92 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by joppelarius:

And you do FAILZ.

Whatever. Why don’t you try spelling your verb forms correctly in stead of attempting to lolspeak. ’Cause in that language YOU fail. Epic fail. -

Lol I think he knows how to spell ur just mad cuz you FAILZ

 
avatar for sonic6676 sonic6676 13 posts
Flag Post

guys somewhat like final fantasy tactics or like something else but i dont think its illegal

 
avatar for Invader_Zim1987 Invader_Zim1987 1 post
Flag Post

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v297/thor1/LOLcats/save-the-internet.jpg
I think i found Joppelarius’s photo online

 
avatar for jokeftw jokeftw 43 posts
Flag Post

Should epic Battle Fantasy be sued for using FF content? (That actually was a big compilation of several RPG games)

 
avatar for lambard667 lambard667 621 posts
Flag Post

Don’t bump dead threads. Dead thread is dead.

 
avatar for koolaidperson koolaidperson 960 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by joppelarius:

Pfuh I was just having fun, stop being so serious. I was just kidding! ;-)

Yeah you were kidding, get out of here! You were arguing it for like 10 posts and then you realized you were getting owned so you said it was a joke. Quit covering it up and delete the thread. (EPIC FAILZ)

It can’t be deleted because it didn’t use same characters (or names for similar characters) and it didn’t copy individually copyrighted names and units. I’m not an expert on copright laws but if its been out for a long time on a major website it would of be destroyed by legal divisions if it copied advanced wars.

Also EPIC FAILZ!!!!

 
avatar for DeathCrunch DeathCrunch 318 posts
Flag Post
Originally posted by Mureth:

If it’s like Advance Wars, then It’s Final Fantasy Tactics Advanced which means it’s like that game which i think was called, Orcs and some free online game…

Tactics Ogre.
OP if your legit your astoundingly stupid. Rest of you, go play Shining Force. It’s the original and therefore most badass.

Sign in to reply