how am i ignoring you? you say it is piss easy to find servers without the randomness. it is clearly difficult enough that you cannot just search for them through tags. if you have to use some websites or something likek tf2lobby (which is flawed enough that i wouldnt even consider it) then it is definitely not piss easy as you say. perhaps i am just so stupid that i cannot find this supposedly piss easy method of finding these servers. it would sure be nice if you would actually tell me how you find these non random servers so easily
you cant really directly relate skill required on reaction time vs planning as both are important skills for just about any fps and it is irrelevant whether one is more important than the other. you should never just remove or lessen reaction time for planning or planning for reaction time for they are not inversely proportional. im not even really sure why you brought this up as it doesnt really have anything to do with this discussion.
from what i remember stars players were about as good as some of the other best public server players which is still pretty disappointing. again this is pretty unrelated to the discussion