[No sign-ups] There is only one truth page 3 (locked)

177 posts

Flag Post
Originally posted by Jaskaran2000:

Hmm.

Was the first weapon a ranged weapon?

No

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Was A getting hanged? EDIT: Derp

B had some kind of relation with A?

The fake suicide was a public event?

B is as important than A? Or is B more important?

Yes
no
No and No

 
Flag Post

A is dead?

If A is dead, B killed A?

If B killed A, where money the motifs? Or was some kind of revenge?

 
Flag Post

Alright, time to note down what we have.

-Person B was near the scene when it happened but not at the scene per se.
-Person A was an important figure.
-Person A died of blood loss.
-Person A was kinda fugitive.
-Person A’s death process was observes by people who weren’t B.
-Another person took a significant action.
-Person A died by a different weapon than when he tried to fake suicide.
-The first weapon was a melee, but not a sword/dagger/knife
-The second weapon was a knife/dagger.
-There were two more important people, Person C and D
-B had a relation with A.

Did C see the murder happen?
Did D see the murder happen?

 
Flag Post

Weapon #1 was something that could cause stabbing wounds?

C & D had any relations with A or B?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Behemoth542:

A is dead?

If A is dead, B killed A?

If B killed A, where money the motifs? Or was some kind of revenge?

Yes
yes
Indirectly Money. No revenge

Did C see the murder happen? Did D see the murder happen?

Both didn’t.

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Weapon #1 was something that could cause stabbing wounds?

C & D had any relations with A or B?

No
A yes, B no

 
Flag Post

Was there even a weapon involved in A faking suicide?

Was A in some elevated position where he was giving a speech or doing a similar activity that allowed the crowd of all the other people to see A?

Did much time pass from the time when A faked suicide to the part where A is found stabbed and bled out?

Was the faked suicide attempt observed by the crowd?

Was the stabbing of A with a short stabbing blade observed by the crowd?

Did the crowd do anything important? Did the crowd do anything to A? Did it happen during the first event if it did? Did it happen during the second event if it did?

Is the gender of A relevant?

Is the gender of B not the same as gender of A?

Is B a criminal in other ways than having contributed to death of A?

Are other items/objects other than the weapons involved?

 
Flag Post

Is this all a dream dreamt up by Person A?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Minnakht:

Was there even a weapon involved in A faking suicide?

Was A in some elevated position where he was giving a speech or doing a similar activity that allowed the crowd of all the other people to see A?

Did much time pass from the time when A faked suicide to the part where A is found stabbed and bled out?

Was the faked suicide attempt observed by the crowd?

Was the stabbing of A with a short stabbing blade observed by the crowd?

Did the crowd do anything important? Did the crowd do anything to A? Did it happen during the first event if it did? Did it happen during the second event if it did?

Is the gender of A relevant?

Is the gender of B not the same as gender of A?

Is B a criminal in other ways than having contributed to death of A?

Are other items/objects other than the weapons involved?

No
No
I cannot give you an answer, since it would lead to errors. But let’s say it’s not immediately
No
No, no,
no
no
Yes
In the original story, yes, but for the sake of simplicity, I choose to irrelevant how B killed A.

Originally posted by videogames518:

Is this all a dream dreamt up by Person A?

No, but I like your out of the box thinking.

 
Flag Post

Was the fact A did something that looked like suicide known to the crowd?

Was B the first to find out A wasn’t actually dead?


There were loads of people in the area, but apart from a and B, only 2 were important.

Did any of the other people take any significant action? Yes

Did the crowd do anything important? Did the crowd do anything to A? Did it happen during the first event if it did? Did it happen during the second event if it did? No, no

I fail to see how is this not contradictory, sadly.

 
Flag Post

B is some kind of mercenary or something like that?

A was stabbed Post-Mortem?

C and/or D are family of A? If not, co-worker?

Is it possible to fake a suicide by stabbing without something that, you know, stabs?

 
Flag Post

Was Person A actually murdered?

Was Person A’s death an accident?

Was the first weapon used to fake his death a syringe?

Did the fake suicide cause the real suicide?

Did anyone else die?

Was Person C a sibling of Person A? Was Person D a relative of Person A?

Was the man’s real death meant to be staged?

 
Flag Post

Was the “inside” a vehicle?
Is this some kind of EMT/Ambulance shenanigans?
Are the details of the fake suicide (eg. Where/How) important?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Minnakht:

Was the fact A did something that looked like suicide known to the crowd?

Was B the first to find out A wasn’t actually dead?


There were loads of people in the area, but apart from a and B, only 2 were important.

Did any of the other people take any significant action? Yes

Did the crowd do anything important? Did the crowd do anything to A? Did it happen during the first event if it did? Did it happen during the second event if it did? No, no

I fail to see how is this not contradictory, sadly.

No
He knew it the whole time.

You said crowd. And no, the crowd didn’t do anything. The yes applies to other people, not the crowd

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

B is some kind of mercenary or something like that?

A was stabbed Post-Mortem?

C and/or D are family of A? If not, co-worker?

Is it possible to fake a suicide by stabbing without something that, you know, stabs?

No
No
No and No
Yes

Originally posted by Crash301:

Was Person A actually murdered?

Was Person A’s death an accident?

Was the first weapon used to fake his death a syringe?

Did the fake suicide cause the real suicide?

Did anyone else die?

Was Person C a sibling of Person A? Was Person D a relative of Person A?

Was the man’s real death meant to be staged?

Yes
No
No
No
No
No
Staged how?

Originally posted by funiax:

Was the “inside” a vehicle?
Is this some kind of EMT/Ambulance shenanigans?
Are the details of the fake suicide (eg. Where/How) important?

Yes
No
Kinda, where and how are important.

 
Flag Post

The vehicle is important?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Behemoth542:

The vehicle is important?

Yes. Also the kind of.

 
Flag Post

Did any natural force (like pressure, oxigen) had any to do with the death?

The car was a roof less one? (forgot how it was said)

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Did any natural force (like pressure, oxigen) had any to do with the death?

The car was a roof less one? (forgot how it was said)

No
How do you assume it’s a car. Unfounded assumtion.

 
Flag Post

The vehicle had a roof?

There was any puddle of water around?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Behemoth542:

The vehicle had a roof?

There was any puddle of water around?

Yes, of course
No.

You dissapoint me.

 
Flag Post

Was the vehicle

-a car?
-a minibus?
-a truck?

Was B a serial killer?

Did A’s fake suicide go wrong and hurt A?

 
Flag Post

Hey, I’m not the best one.

B owed money to A? Viceversa?

A was some kind of ruler?

Something like this had happened in real life?

If A was not a ruler, was he/she a politician?

 
Flag Post

How about a train? Trains are common.

Tunnel?

Right…

Was it dark when A was murdered?

Was it dark due to time of day? Or was it circumstances?

I don’t smell a tunnel, my nose’s stuffy. It’s cold here. Winter.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by hamuka:

Was the vehicle

-a car?
-a minibus?
-a truck?

Was B a serial killer?

Did A’s fake suicide go wrong and hurt A?

No to all

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Hey, I’m not the best one.

B owed money to A? Viceversa?

A was some kind of ruler?

Something like this had happened in real life?

If A was not a ruler, was he/she a politician?

No and No
No
No, maybe, not that I know of
No

Originally posted by Minnakht:

How about a train? Trains are common.

Tunnel?

Right…

Was it dark when A was murdered?

Was it dark due to time of day? Or was it circumstances?

I don’t smell a tunnel, my nose’s stuffy. It’s cold here. Winter.

Yes, trains is correct
there was a tunnel
No, not dark

 
Flag Post

A was in the same wagon than B, C or D?

B was in the same wagon than C or D?

C was in the same wagon than D?

The fake suicide was inside the train?

The murder was inside the train?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Behemoth542:

A was in the same wagon than B, C or D?

B was in the same wagon than C or D?

C was in the same wagon than D?

The fake suicide was inside the train?

The murder was inside the train?

At which time? They changed through the time.
Yes the last two questions.