[No sign-ups] There is only one truth page 5 (locked)

Well, I’ll leave the rest to everyone else, then. I’m out of ideas.

Was A murdered in the toilet?
err.. Was C a close friend of A? Was D?
Did C and/or D help A plan the fake suicide?

Originally posted by thijsel:

Was A murdered in the toilet?
err.. Was C a close friend of A? Was D?
Did C and/or D help A plan the fake suicide?

Yes
No, both disliked him.
No, they knew nothing.

A was part of a mafia or any other crime organization?

B was part of a mafia or any other crime organization?

B was in the same group than A? (Mafia, crime, etc)

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

A was part of a mafia or any other crime organization?

B was part of a mafia or any other crime organization?

B was in the same group than A? (Mafia, crime, etc)

Yes to all

Also, I have a picture, that could help you, but it contains an information, you have not yet thought about.

I don’t see why it cannot be shared.

A and B where Yakuza?

B had a grudge against A?

B was a hitman?

A was B boss?

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

I don’t see why it cannot be shared.

A and B where Yakuza?

B had a grudge against A?

B was a hitman?

No
No
No

Originally posted by efar:

A was B boss?

No

Because you asked so nicely.

The dead person is A, the head is C.

Lemme take a wild guess. He was a wanted man. He faked suicide so that the hunters wouldn’t kill him because they thought he was dead. Then they found out. You know what happens.

Originally posted by S_98:

Lemme take a wild guess. He was a wanted man. He faked suicide so that the hunters wouldn’t kill him because they thought he was dead. Then they found out. You know what happens.

Yes at wanted man. No to the rest.

Off topic question: Is that Conan (the anime)?

Topic questions: C & D where in the same group than A & B?

C had some kind of relation with A’s fake suicide and/or death?

And D?

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Off topic question: Is that Conan (the anime)?

Topic questions: C & D where in the same group than A & B?

C had some kind of relation with A’s fake suicide and/or death?

And D?

Please don’t use that info for your advantage.
Different groups
Hard to tell, C saw the “suicide”. D didn’t. Both didn’t see the murder.
No

C & D are enemies of A & B?

A used a tool to stab himself?

B used a domestic knife?

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

C & D are enemies of A & B?

A used a tool to stab himself?

B used a domestic knife?

Yes
No
Irrelevant.

A’s death was because B betrayed him?

B was a woman?

If B was a woman, did she was A’s lover?

Why am I the only one guessing?

Are we focusing on non-important details?

Was B forced to kill A?
Did B want to kill A? Was it a situation where it was absolutely necessary for B to kill A? If it wasn’t, would B not have killed A?
Did A betray B first?

Were C/D there to kill A?
Were C/D there to kill B?
Did B die within 10 minuets of killing A?

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

A’s death was because B betrayed him?

B was a woman?

If B was a woman, did she was A’s lover?

Why am I the only one guessing?

Yes
No
No
Because others ran out of ideas.

Originally posted by funiax:

Are we focusing on non-important details?

Was B forced to kill A?
Did B want to kill A? Was it a situation where it was absolutely necessary for B to kill A? If it wasn’t, would B not have killed A?
Did A betray B first?

Not really, but for example the gender of B is irrelevant.

Not given, probably forced by himself.
Yes. Probably. Probably.
No

Originally posted by efar:

Were C/D there to kill A?
Were C/D there to kill B?
Did B die within 10 minuets of killing A?

No to all.

Wild guess:

A and B where travelling in train. B job was to protect A, and he went to check the other wagons. B sent a text message to A, telling him that C and D, members of the rival gang, where looking for him. A then went to the bathroom and faked the suicide. C entered it and saw A “dying”. After C left the bathroom, B, who was paid by a third faction, entered and killed A, betraying him

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Wild guess:

A and B where travelling in train. B job was to protect A, and he went to check the other wagons. B sent a text message to A, telling him that C and D, members of the rival gang, where looking for him. A then went to the bathroom and faked the suicide. C entered it and saw A “dying”. After C left the bathroom, B, who was paid by a third faction, entered and killed A, betraying him

Sorry for late reply. No.

Could you tell me which parts are right and which don’t of my guess?

Originally posted by Behemoth542:

Could you tell me which parts are right and which don’t of my guess?

Okay.
A and B where travelling in train. They were on the train, but not really voluntary.
B job was to protect A, and he went to check the other wagons. Nope
B sent a text message to A, telling him that C and D, members of the rival gang, where looking for him. No, but C&D were members of a enemy faction.
A then went to the bathroom and faked the suicide. Pretty much, without any details.
C entered it and saw A “dying”. Without your context, that is actually correct.
After C left the bathroom, B, who was paid by a third faction, entered and killed A, betraying him. No to paid by third faction, but yes to the rest.

10 days I left this alone. Is anyone still interested in this? I’ll even give you a hint.

I’m just plain out of guesses

I’m interested in… not this particular bloody puzzle. Proved to be too frustrating for sure.

Skip to the next one.