Forums The Arts

SOTW#11 - Voting (locked)

25 posts

Flag Post

Voting will be as follows:
(No voting for yourself)
1st - Reason 2nd - Reason 3rd - Reason
1st choice will get 3pts, 2nd choice will get 2pts, and 3rd choice will get 1pt. Points will be
added up and whoever gets the most points will win.
If you do not vote this way, your vote will NOT count.

On a side note: This is a record SOTW, with 15 different entrees!

WiiPlayer113

ozzy123

DeadFire1991

moomanmatt

DeadSoulReaper

Craig12390

krick19

yuyuter

craigkiller

Kool_A1d

killer121

Oboe_Passion

Ncio

snice

ojad0

 
Flag Post

i was nearly about to enter my first ever one lol but anyways:
1. ojad0 i like the way everything revolves around the flower and also how the middle of it looks like a cystal
2. ozzy123 the end of the leaf is a bit weird but everything else about it seems cool especially the reflection, the name and the bit around the outside of the leaf
3. toughy.. probs mmm because it looks kinda like the clown fish is breaking out of some grey world and bringing colour… No? just me then..

I really felt like going for ncios or dsr

 
Flag Post

1~ moomanmatt’s entry is very simple and flow is obvious, I think. Strange white semi-transparent octagon on the eye though o.O
2~ krick19 has demonstrated his usual skill with the smudge brush. Flow is straight forward, but the text and the head are both focals…
3~ ojad0 has grasped flow well, I believe, and this sig fits well under the theme “Nature”.

Enough serious talk. I believe we all had a hard time on this one.

 
Flag Post

DeadSoulReaper #1
Ojad #2
Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

 
Flag Post

Nico #1
DeadSoulReaper #2
moomanmatt #3

 
Flag Post

Oh my god!

So hard but it has to be
1. Ncio
2. Craigkiller
3. ozzy123’s

 
Flag Post

@ Three people above. You have to give a reason for each vote!

1st – ojad0 – Sweet colours. Great photo manip. Awesome effects. Nice job.
2nd – moomanmatt – Great compo. Nice colours. Bad text. Good flow.
3rd – yuyuter – Weird Sig, but I love it. No flow. Bit of depth. Nice text. Awesome compo. Sweet job. =D

 
Flag Post

1st – Yuyuter
I like the vector feel and its got a lot of depth with layers of the tree and so on.

2nd – Krick19
It made me laugh!

3rd – Ncio
Good flow and I like the massive contrast between the picture and the … comet?

Can I just say I’m disappointed that Ncio and ojad managed to get there entries in! I think I would have had a much better chance if they weren’t in! (7 points so far! Come on! Ojad has 9 and Ncio has…)

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1

Ojad #2

Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Originally posted by jandel122:

Nico #1

DeadSoulReaper #2

moomanmatt #3

Originally posted by ruudiluca:

Oh my god!

So hard but it has to be

1. Ncio

2. Craigkiller

3. ozzy123’s

You need to give reasons guys!

 
Flag Post

#1:

Krick wins my top vote. He has created a good composed sig, using careful colour choice and extremely delicate experience.

#2:

DSR wins my second vote. Good control of focal and flow.

#3

Ncio wins my final vote, for good manipulation and colour control.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1

Ojad #2

Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Like really DSR? You had an alt vote for you?

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by krick19:
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1


Ojad #2


Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Like really DSR? You had an alt vote for you?

Krick, why arn’t you voting? So there’s more chance of you winning? Not cool.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Ncio:
Originally posted by krick19:
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1



Ojad #2



Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Like really DSR? You had an alt vote for you?

Krick, why arn’t you voting? So there’s more chance of you winning? Not cool.

Yeah pretty much. I’m a complete jerk, and I’m obsessed with winning. Or maybe I had breakfast. Maybe you shouldn’t make accusations when there’s still a whole week left to vote.

1st: Yuyuter.
I’m kind of a sucker for pixel art, and the gradient in the water is really well done. The tree is also pretty nicely done.

2nd:MMM
A better effort could be made to blend the focal, but the effects in the background are pretty nice.

3rd: Ojad0
Fractal work is very nice, and the colors are great.

Honorable Mention: ncio
Wanted to vote for this, but the palm tree and background just kill it for me (way too LQ).

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by moomanmatt:
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1


Ojad #2


Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Originally posted by jandel122:

Nico #1


DeadSoulReaper #2


moomanmatt #3

Originally posted by ruudiluca:

Oh my god!

So hard but it has to be


1. Ncio


2. Craigkiller


3. ozzy123’s

You need to give reasons guys!

SHHHHhhhhh!!! i’m fnly gunna get 2 votes in a SOTW!!!

1st place: Yuyuter- its a nice sig overall, a very calm feeling.

2nd place: oJad0- Its pretty cool, so very mystical O_o…

3rd place: craig123- just choosin from wuts left…

 
Flag Post

1st: Oboe_Passion
Reason: it is very calm and relaxing just like nature well some of it (damn volcanoes) the horse is done wonderful it looks great.

2nd: DeadSoulReaper
Reason: the bird is great the sky is wonderful and its nice how the bird is going in to the light.

3rd: Ojad0
Reason: it’s good to me it looks like it makes the waves it pushes out and it comes back to it i like it the color was great.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by krick19:
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1


Ojad #2


Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Like really DSR? You had an alt vote for you?

I was joking when I said Kool was my alt >.>

 
Flag Post

Oh alright, sorry.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by ozzy123:
Originally posted by moomanmatt:
Originally posted by Kool_A1d:

DeadSoulReaper #1



Ojad #2



Ncio #3

Those are all really cool.

Originally posted by jandel122:

Nico #1



DeadSoulReaper #2



moomanmatt #3

Originally posted by ruudiluca:

Oh my god!

So hard but it has to be



1. Ncio



2. Craigkiller



3. ozzy123’s

You need to give reasons guys!

SHHHHhhhhh!!! i’m fnly gunna get 2 votes in a SOTW!!!

1st place: Yuyuter- its a nice sig overall, a very calm feeling.

2nd place: oJad0- Its pretty cool, so very mystical O_o…

3rd place: craig123- just choosin from wuts left…

Ozzy, you have only done you voting because you don’t want anyone else to win. You picked craigs over Ncios and even mine. Its insulting! (sorry craig)

 
Flag Post

Pfft. So he likes one better than another? We dont all have the same views.

 
Flag Post

Oh no, I can’t win an internet contest! How horrible!

 
Flag Post

II agree with Moomanmatt, kruck19 is a nube. lol!

 
Flag Post

Stop the conversations now.

I’m fed up with telling you guys not to discuss in the entry and voting threads, and this is the
last straw. There is no reason that you should be quoting others, and no reason why
you should be having conversations here.

You also shouldn’t be telling others to provide reasons. That’s my job, being that I can do
it in a more efficient manner. If somebody doesn’t provide reasons, their vote simply won’t
count. No hassle, no trouble.

Consider this a final warning. If any of you persist with this I’ll begin not allowing you to
participate in SOTW at all.

I really don’t want to do that- but I will if necessary.

 
Flag Post

1st- Oboe_Passion, I dont know why but I just like it…(Is that an acceptable reason?)
2nd- ozzy123, All the contrasting colors stand out… so I like it…
3rd- killer121, Although its not very fancy, I like how the color flows on the left side..

 
Flag Post

MANY OF YOU DID NOT PROVIDE REASONS TO YOUR VOTES, SO YOUR VOTES DIDN’T COUNT!

VOTING ENDS NOW!

FINAL SCORES!

ojad0 _ 11
yuyuter _ 10
moomanmatt _ 8
krick19 _ 7
Oboe_Passion _ 6
DeadSoulReaper _ 5
ozzy123 _ 4
Ncio _ 2
craigkiller _ 1
killer121 _ 1
WiiPlayer113 _ 0
DeadFire1991 _ 0
Craig12390 _ 0
Kool_A1d _ 0
snice _ 0

Congratulations, ojad0, For winning SOTW#11!

I hope to see you, and other participants in future SOTW’s.

Sincerely, hokage4354.

 
Flag Post

SO CLOSE! Oh well :)