Would it be immoral to have sex with aliens?

103 posts

Flag Post

So an alien race comes to earth. Assuming said race has standard human genders, would it be immoral to have sexual relations with one? Discuss.

 
Flag Post

I, personally, feel repulsed by the idea, but assuming the aliens consent, I am suppose not…

 
Flag Post

Human ganders? Whilst human geese is a novel concept, I will assume you meant genders. The OP is woefully short on description and detail, and misses many salient facts about such a scenario.

A big one is that even if they have a male gender and a female gender, being a different species, and likely from a completely different family, there is next to no chance whatsoever that your genitals will be compatible with theirs.

For an example, try picturing yourself having sexual intercourse with a bumble bee, or say, an electric eel. Both come from species with two genders, but well, there are severe logistical problems presented.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by vikaTae:
Human ganders? Whilst human geese is a novel concept, I will assume you meant genders. The OP is woefully short on description and detail, and misses many salient facts about such a scenario.

First, people make typos. Get over it. Secondly, you don’t need a long, detailed OP to spark a deep interesting discussion.

A big one is that even if they have a male gender and a female gender, being a different species, and likely from a completely different family, there is next to no chance whatsoever that your genitals will be compatible with theirs.
I was hoping you could just infer that my hypothetical aliens WERE compatible with humans. If they weren’t, I wouldn’t need to ask this question. Anyways, they still need openings in their body to eat or excrete, leaving actually very likely that sex of some form is possible.
 
Flag Post

Only if these requirements are met:

1. The aliens need to be able to be communicated with.
2. They need to consent.
3. Only after it is clear they do not have any transmittable diseases that we can’t resist should it even be allowed.
4. Personally, you would want at least a decent level of attraction.
5. It needs to be possible.

 
Flag Post

And preferably any potential offspring won’t live in pain for some reason.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Darkscanner:
Secondly, you don’t need a long, detailed OP to spark a deep interesting discussion.

You do however, need to cover all the bases and give some actual direction for the discussion to head in. Right now, it is extremely short, and frankly, liable to get locked unless it is fleshed out some. The typo I mentioned because it brought an amusing anthropomorphic image to mind, in conjunction with the phrase running through my mind “What is good for the goose is good for the gander”.

I was hoping you could just infer that my hypothetical aliens WERE compatible with humans.

Too much to infer. Besides, it might be much more interesting if they were not strictly compatible. Who hasn’t had wistful dreams of tentacles, or half-visible creatures with leathery wings?

If they weren’t, I wouldn’t need to ask this question. Anyways, they still need openings in their body to eat or excrete, leaving actually very likely that sex of some form is possible.

If you wish to stick bits of your anatomy inside the poo-hole of a killer whale, who am I to stop you? Of course, it would be rather amusing if your aliens ground up their waste just prior to ejecting it.

It would be a rather fun time to discover they had symbiotic leeches living on their skin as well.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by vikaTae:
Originally posted by Darkscanner:
Secondly, you don’t need a long, detailed OP to spark a deep interesting discussion.

You do however, need to cover all the bases and give some actual direction for the discussion to head in. Right now, it is extremely short, and frankly, liable to get locked unless it is fleshed out some. The typo I mentioned because it brought an amusing anthropomorphic image to mind, in conjunction with the phrase running through my mind “What is good for the goose is good for the gander”.

I was hoping you could just infer that my hypothetical aliens WERE compatible with humans.

Too much to infer. Besides, it might be much more interesting if they were not strictly compatible. Who hasn’t had wistful dreams of tentacles, or half-visible creatures with leathery wings?

If they weren’t, I wouldn’t need to ask this question. Anyways, they still need openings in their body to eat or excrete, leaving actually very likely that sex of some form is possible.

If you wish to stick bits of your anatomy inside the poo-hole of a killer whale, who am I to stop you? Of course, it would be rather amusing if they ground up their waste just prior to ejecting it.

Dear god, you don’t leave much to the imagination, now do you?

Anyway, as long as they consent, can’t see anything wrong with it. Nothing wrong about two consenting intelligent species getting it on.

 
Flag Post

At least you aren’t eating, 1132.

I don’t see much more to discuss unless the OP is fleshed out though.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by 1132:

Dear god, you don’t leave much to the imagination, now do you?

I would hardly be doing my job as a wordsmith of some talent if I was not capable of getting your imagination all fired up and redlining with a scant few lines, if I put my mind to it :)

But yea, I left a LOT to the imagination. Although I get the feeling your imagination is very industriously filling in all the gaps. :)

Anyway, as long as they consent, can’t see anything wrong with it. Nothing wrong about two consenting intelligent species getting it on.

True, its just the logistics would be a fun mental exercise, and quite likely a good physical workout too.

 
Flag Post

I have a feeling this will get way off track very soon.

I also have a feeling it will either get very, very awkward or very, very fun.

 
Flag Post

If they looked attractive to me, I’d be morally fine with it providing they gave consent.

 
Flag Post

I believe having sex with any non human is believed immoral by the general public.

 
Flag Post

Personally, I can’t think of any reason it would be intrinsically immoral. I can think of reasons it would be a bad idea, but not immoral.

 
Flag Post

I don’t believe anything is immoral, but I would probably never do it myself. It is just not how I roll.

 
Flag Post

Assuming the OP (and we have to ASSUME a lot on this one) is limiting this “sex-w/-aliens” to pleasure—rather than any form of procreation….I’ll leave the decision about my “interest” in pretty much ANYTHING that is “humanoid”….leave it up to “Spike”, my “other brain”.

If “he” ain’t interested….
I’m sure NOT gonna “push the issue”. 0¿~

As for other ppl…
it’s pretty much the same as it is now….
If it’s consenting,,,,of age,,,,relatively “private”….
then, who am I to judge?

 
Flag Post

After all the people who have been anally probed over the years, I’m all about getting something back. Stick it to the dirty, dirty aliens.

 
Flag Post

It is humanoid, has 46 chromosomes and a vagina that I can comfortably fit in, and I’m not related to it, I’m in.

 
Flag Post
Originally posted by onlineidiot1994:

It is humanoid, has 46 chromosomes and a vagina that I can comfortably fit in, and I’m not related to it, I’m in.

Lol, what if it has four mouths (each with a phalanx), eight arms lined with suckers, three legs, both sets of genitals, and three heads, each with an exposed cranium?

 
This post has been removed by an administrator or moderator
 
Flag Post
Originally posted by Darkruler2005:

Only if these requirements are met:

1. The aliens need to be able to be communicated with.
2. They need to consent.
3. Only after it is clear they do not have any transmittable diseases that we can’t resist should it even be allowed.
4. Personally, you would want at least a decent level of attraction.
5. It needs to be possible.

And what if I wanted to have sex with an ape? That would be immoral, correct? But what if the monkey offers consent through the means of initiating the sexual practices (e.g. grabs my penis and starts jerking me off)? And what if the ape has no diseases? And we’re both attracted to each other?

>>Breeding with a different species is immoral.

 
Flag Post

Can we please keep the discussion civil and not resort to untasteful (not a word but shhh!) references. Thanks!

 
This post has been removed by an administrator or moderator
 
Flag Post

I believe having sex with any non human is believed immoral by the general public.

That’s only because none of them currently can give legal consent.

But what if the monkey offers consent through the means of initiating the sexual practices

No legal consent, end of story. If the aliens are considered intelligent enough to consent on their own, then they will be able to give legal consent. We can’t communicate well enough with all other lifeforms, currently.

 
Flag Post

Heres what i say:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3b6pXwK914s