Under rating threshold (hideshow)
At one point item management gets really time consuming and uncomfortable. If there was perhaps a sort button by item stats it would help a lot.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
After three games where melees have had to sit at the back of the bus, it's high time to give them some love, don't you think? Give Spearmen a range of two, they have spears after all. Let Paladins sacrifice themselves to keep a monster from putting you below one life. Let a sneaky type pair up with one across a path and catch/hit flying enemies that get right between them. Have Barbarians cleave multiple enemies within reach. Be creative but please do something so they aren't so underpowered compared to ranged types.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I would prefer they keep these lengthy Badges of the Day later in the week instead of on Monday, so those with less time on their hands can spend the week working on it, instead of giving us a single day.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
After completing 9 different quest i realized you can get the badge by just repeating the first one again and again and again. Vote up so people dont waste their time
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
If your game is not saving, make sure your not clearing the cookies and history from your computer as game files save, make sure your browser also does not clear history upon exit. It can be a security feature check your settings and stop complaining.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Everyone who has the main menu bug report it using the "report bug" feature in the section just below achievements under the game window. Don't just talk about it here and expect the devs to see what your saying.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
-"Alright crossbowmen! We need to stop that flying dragon."
-"No problem sir, I'll shoot its ankle. it'll slow its flying down for good."
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
No, you cannot sell units. The game gained lots of things with the campaign mode, but also lost the simplicity of before. Also it's too complicated to achieve a good strategy for some levels and you have to wait until you find the ideal general.
Pretty enjoyable as all the protectors
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Consecration increases damage against enemies that have a strength against your Heroes element. After three consecration boosts (which can be reduced by the Elemental stat on your Hero), your heroes effectively have an elemental advanage over two elements. (please + to keep it up, so many people ask this.)
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I was wondering if you could include a description of the effects of the inflictions that units inflict on their enemies, as all of us are not avid players of the series.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
There are 26 Storyline Quests (takes a while). Do not use melee units. Max your hero's Ranged or Magic Use accordingly. Save heroes with good unit pairings regardless of element -- there are items that change elements later in the game.
With 38 Magic Use, 22 Elemental, and 14 Base attack power, I cleared most maps with only 4 units placed.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I really think that Melee units get passed over because they are useless against flying, maybe make them only able to hit flying units. I suggest instead of being unable to attack flying units, give Melee units a penalty while attacking Flying units. ( -50% attack rate, +15% dodge rate etc.) I would love to use Melee more but honestly they just aren't worth it right now. I feel like I'm missing some of the game. Anyone else feel that way?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
This protector's really good, just a few things that I'd like to see: 1) Selling units in battle. I don't know how many times I've placed the wrong unit or just wanted to change it, but I couldn't. I've actually lost because of this before. 2) Customizing unit's AI. Like say always attack first or last, or attack weakest or strongest or ones without the status effects that you give, or attack every other one. 3) More info on stuff. Preferably in the protectopedia like before, but as long as you can see more stats on your units and enemy units, it'd be good. 4) Make melee soldiers worth a darn after the first two missions. Either make them stronger, bigger range or some that can hit flying. Anyway, this is still a great game, and I hope you make some of these changes in Protector V at least. 5/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
the looks of it is like candy for the eyes and is just so far above and beyond what has come before. the music, just so much better. drew me in when I was letting it load up. About to start playing a game in a series that has shown me that some developers, well a developer, that I've followed can not just stedily improve, but improve drastically with each step. Even venturing out to try new styles and do them well. Thank you kind sir, for putting your talents on display for all of us and not taking over the world... but it would be an awesome world if you took it over....
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
A wonderful game, and the best Protector to date in my opinion. If there's anything I could suggest to make this better, it would be to expand the Protectopedia to include more details on gameplay mechanics: such as descriptions of special abilities, and even the basic stats of units. I still don't even know exactly what most of the abilities do, just what I can guess using common sense. Overall, though, a great game, and deserves my 5-star rating and favorite. Keep up the great games!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I'd like the protectopedia to be more precise about the different things ... Like what is consecration ? I don't have a clue there.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Get a hero with the Protectorate's ranged units (patroler and defender) ASAP and use that hero only for the rest of the game. Put all level ups towards ranged for both you and the hero. Those are OP due to consecrate, which negates any weakness your element has to any mobs.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Great game, more indepth strategy needed, also nice RPG style upgrading. Overall definately worth playing for quite sometime. Also "lol" at the "Time Wasted" heading for time spent on game :P
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I'm not really sure that items that increase steal chance actually do anything, even when equipped to cutpurse and gentleman.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
@Black_Death1400: The steal bonus only applies if the unit itself can even try to steal in the first place. Get a hero who can recruit cutpurses.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
@BLYXX: it's not Kong "borrowing" from other sites; developers rarely host their games on a single website. Why would you?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
One thing I found wrong in this game, well more of an inconvenience, is that the talents are ordered randomly. This leads to a lot of excess effort when looking for how to acquire talents. Maybe you could group them by how they are obtained i.e. all acquired from consumables in one group and all gained from quests in another.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Buying the Investor talent off a scroll gives a +5 gold per completed quest talent. That means you need to do 400(FOUR HUNDRED) quests just to recoup the initial investment in the talent scroll! O.o
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Great game! The one thing I wish is that there were some way to sort items. Even the ability to highlight which items will, say, change my hero's element -- without having to laboriously search through dozens of roll-over texts, since you can't tell what an item does by looking at it -- would be an improvement.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Me too Ascander, originally I had intended to do the same for this.. But it became obvious having a coloured sprite for each unit in each element would require so much art, time and file space it just wasn't possible. Let alone the restrictions of flash. Even with 46 variations things were getting slow to work with. If I'd elementalized them all in the way Protector III does I'd be looking at 230 individual sprites, about a 9mb filesize and a very high cost just to have coloured clothes on the units... If you then imagine having 4 levels so that they visually improve on level up... 920 sprites. Obviously I had to come up with another solution.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
from PatoFeliz (I didn't see it here in comments):
To what you asked about “elemental” in protector IV. It means that improves the advantage you make with elements. Let’s say that you are fighting an enemy that is cold, and its weakness is fire, and that you would inflict him 50% more damage than usually. With an improvement in elemental, you make 52% of extra damage. And it applies to weakness too. If you attack this enemy with cold, let’s say you would have a 50% damage penalization for hitting him with cold. With “elemental”, this penaliation is reduced to 48%, and so on with every skill point you invest.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Simple suggestion: When you earn a new Talent, it should glow slightly or stand out in some way the first time you visit the 'Skill' page after being awarded it. It is a pain to mouse over all the different talents to find the one you were just awarded and see what it does.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Can you at least be semi-literate if you're not happy with a game? Using text speak like h8 just makes you look funny to others.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
This game needs an in-game explanation of all the terms.
What exactly is "Gold return"? Interest on remaining gold at a wave end? More gold given to you after a mission? More gold per kill?
What about Steal? Is that a chance to increase gold drops from monsters?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
i agree. the real challenge of the game is trying to find out what the elements really look like, otherwise you can end up using physical instead of energy
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
needs a sell unit button desperately. i dont want to have to buy a piece of land just because i put down the wrong unit. other than that 5/5