Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Treasure of Cutlass Reef

« Back to Treasure of Cutlass Reef

gameinabottle

Oct. 15, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) version 1.2 is up! enjoy! :-)

+ - !

(0)

gameinabottle

Oct. 14, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Hey guys, thank you all for the comments, I've set up a to-do list and will upgrade the game soon! Do not except a full rewrite from scratch, so no huge scrolling map nor multi-player this time, but many smaller fixes are planned.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 13, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) why do you make it so that enemy cannonballs hurt other enemies ships? nice game 4/5

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 11, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Simple, still original and pleasant to play. More maps, more IAs, more canonballs types could enhance the whole. 3/5

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 10, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) It was ok.

+ - !

(0)

scrappledog

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) It is Space-Invaderish, now that you mention it. I agree wholeheartedly that if it incorporated a larger map (with said obstacles and natural shields, harbors, etc.) truer sailing physics with variable wind speed and direction (maybe even storms), and more intricate battle tactics, this could be something I played all day long. As it is, I spent several hours on it. But don't OVER-complicate it. I've played and yawned over too many of those kinds. Can anyone recommend something like what I've described?

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) It's... OK. Obviously inspired by Sid Meier's Pirates game, which is no bad thing. But the limited size of the board hurts it rather badly, as does the repetitive style of play. Create a much larger scrolling play map with obstacles (islands and reefs), and real sailing characteristics and I think you'd have a great game here. For now, 3/5.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Am I the only one who thinks this isn't a very good game? Some kind of invisible barrier prevents you from sailing the whole screen and enemy ships just sail back and forth above you, shooting occasionally. What is this, space invaders? At least space invaders wasn't so slow. 2/5

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Very fun, very unique...I'd love to be able to move my ship across all the map though

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) The Game is okay, but it's too easy and gets too repettitive too quick, but it's still good.

+ - !

(0)

DaDude9211

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Fun game and good idea, but if you learn a few maneuvers it's just going through the motions

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) NICE Game...i came to the last lvl and the boss had 500 health left but i there was another ship that killed all my pirates^^

+ - !

(0)

The_Chosen_One

Oct. 09, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) @peplepiu/gameinabattle Or cutthroats.

+ - !

(0)

Alvarenga

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) I cant beat lvl 2 in colonel mode... any tips?

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) A very good idea. Could be faster, though.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Aaaaaaaarrrrr!!!!

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Aaaaaaaarrrrr!!!!

+ - !

(0)

Raka

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Seems like a remake of the ship battle part of Pirates:The legend of Black Kat - but too slow, too boring and far too easy

+ - !

(0)

pepelepiu

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Interesting game. It looks like a simplified version of battle scenes in Pirates! (an old computer game which came out on C64 and other platforms of the old days). If you (gameinabottle) know what game I'm talking about, you might want to check it out for features you can add into future versions. For example, raising and lowering sails, and maybe even raiding land.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) good game other than you only get an amout of cannons

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Pretty easy once you figure out how to do it, aslong as yoi go the opposite direction of the ships and fire you miss their cannons but yours all hit.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) needs a pause button

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) gr8 game ! there's a ps1 game like it but i cant remember the name f it! needs better handling

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Good game, reminds me of an old pirate game that I can't put my finger on. I like the concept a lot b/c it's good old fun, not too technical or overbearing. 4/5, great job!

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Needs music and a badge. Otherwise, it's great.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) sigh i miss pirate ship wars on garrys mod... great great game....

+ - !

(0)

fishtastic

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) spoiler alert: spend all you money on reload&crew 1st

+ - !

(0)

Archaic

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Aside from the cannon ball aspect, ship on ship impact damage would be great.

+ - !

(0)

fissiongames

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Great game, although perhaps the fact that enemy cannonballs do not hit other enemy ships is a bit unrealistic.

+ - !

(0)

Jayhawk

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) I wish it was possible to choose which side fired, not just up wind. If it was possible to use the entire screen for movement it would be even better.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) good, very good, pie

+ - !

(0)

sullimart

Oct. 08, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Yeah! Beat it. Sweet game.

+ - !

(0)

Magikarcher

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) it would be coffers not coffins...

+ - !

(0)

dazzer

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) I'll never complete the last level. lol

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) For those of you who find this hard, purchase crew above all else and reload, then grape shot, and then moving and more cannons etc,

+ - !

(0)

Zacknafein

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) A bad thing is that the enemy cannot be destroyed by "friend" cannonball...that hits only me...it's not very realistic ;) And this thing could help when game become more difficult in creating strategies...using a "close combat" ship as a shield...or something similar ;)

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) too big a skip in difficulty especcially on level 2 how anyone could get past it i will never know 2/5

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) i like idea of cannons of each side, more realistic, needs more info on what upgrades do.

+ - !

(0)

Zakini

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Some more info on your own ship would be nice. Like how many of your cannons are still in tact and not just how many are ready to fire. Something like: "50/60 ready to fire" so you have 60 cannons in tact but only 50 are ready. Knowing what all the upgrades do would be handy as well. Also, it'd be cool if you had a certain number of cannons on each side or had to fire cannons on the correct side. Just a thought.

+ - !

(0)

gammabeam

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Make some improvements + Highscores and I'll rate you a 5! A Storyline would be great!

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) lol i thought it was like space invaders at level 3 too

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Very good game i thought, it would be fun if you made a Realism version and historical battles. But this has got to be a 4-5 stars.

+ - !

(0)

dazzer

Oct. 07, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) A skirmish mode would have been nice. Also, a description of what each upgrade does would also be handy.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) A bit boring

+ - !

(0)

isaac

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) So a lot of the game design didn't really make sense until I realised that the game is actually heavily disguised Space Invaders.. Major props for getting the disguise on so thick that it took me three levels to find it!

+ - !

(0)

Feldspar

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) I changed my mind, this game is good, but it would be better if it had a few changes: A storyline, Ability to past half screen, and the ability to capture ships when you engage and board them would be nice. Then you could capture the enemy flagships and use them in battle.

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) The game is great...but by level 8 or so the whole thing slows down immensly. Every time I or the enemy fires a volley I lose control of my ship until most of the projectiles hit or go off screen.

+ - !

(0)

stealthsilent

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) its called trying it on admiral, its not the same thing, more upgrades......

+ - !

(0)

DrippingPixel

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) absolutely badge-worthy!

+ - !

(0)

deleteduser

Oct. 06, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) i agree with kronos,this game should have a badge!...or something or an achievement!

+ - !

(0)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate