Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Good game but.. I'd say for the arty strikes and air strikes, have your soldiers have "luck" depending how much you have, the chances of you surviving the strikes. I know you're trying to add realism into the game by adding the strikes, but it's really unfair that when I have a decent squad, they get blown away easily. And my arty strikes don't help me either; they damage me more than the enemy.
Also, I dislike the fact that it takes a painfully long time to kill an enemy soldier; I also find it frustrating that you clearly see your soldiers' bullets hit the enemy, but they won't die, and also the fact that when they are in point-blank range, they still can't hit them. Other than that, it's a decent game. I'd give it a 3/5.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Ultimately the problem with this game is that the only possible ending for anyone who plays it is to lose. What's the point in that? "Oh boy, I just spent 16 hours of my life playing this game so that I could last longer before I lost...Yeah!" Screw all that other stuff...make it possible to "win" this game, otherwise there's really no point in playing over and over to "improve" your...well, what am I improving anyway? Isn't it better to lose early and move on to something else rather than prolong the loss and just sit here staring at the hopless little soldiers into which I've invested so much time, being blown up, or dying instantly from a single chance shot from across the screen?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Congratulations...Advancing is now a stupid tactical move, since it's inevitable that Germans will appear at the top of the screen at some point as you are trying to advance.
I just had 8...EIGHT Germans appear at the exact moment my last guy was leaving the screen. Amazingly annoying and ill concieved.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I love this game but the AI for the flamethrowers is frustrating. I've yet to not lose my own guys from Friendly fire
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
a not bad game need a quicker way to get points though i could survive a bit longer if i could get the pionts quicker
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
"Spam" is used to describe sending unsolicited messages to someone. Please stop using it to describe using the same function in a game over and over. Makes you sound like idiot kids who don't know anything.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Somehow my last game didn't save. I already made Captain and got one of the ribbons...now I just made Captain again. If it wasn't such a ponderous f*cking game to slog through I wouldn't mind so bad, but this effectively erased two hours of my life. F*ck!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Needs a bunch of polish. I had all my guys at the top of the screen and the terrain didn't advance. The rules don't explain enough about the actual details. I have to assume the calculations are very simple. A number of typos and misspellings.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
for the love of god plzzzz fix when they throw grenades...when your people just come in and the decide to throw a grenade and it only reaches half way accros the map where you got all your trenches....not a very pretty sight
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I don't know if it's just my luck or what. But whenever I play, I immediately lose on further waves with an artillery strike or dozens of Germans rush in with bazooka's and grenade spam me, in one game I had a bunker, 2 trenches and a sizable gunner squad, smashed by 5 grenades that hit directly. =/ Love the game, just not the spontaneous spamming.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Weird, I put all points to resistance soldiers and the german army just stopped in place XD, but there should be a balanced scale between maps and soldier levels
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Great game.
A few suggestions:
Make the surrender button not take you directly back to the main menu but to the score submission screen. This is because once one finds a very good strategy, it's nearly impossible to lose.
Make Tank AI better. I had 3 tanks at one point, but they never fired once at enemy jeeps or tanks....just the troops.
Aside from that, I look forward to Mud and Blood 3. (Just don't make it medieval!)
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Deserve a 1/5 Forever
German soldier deals way too much damage, always killing your men with a hit or 2.
But you need to fire at them a lot just for killing one WTF ?
Even with 100 exp tour soldier are dumb, and keep firing on a disabled foe, so other german could shoot with 100% accuracy and damage ...
Not to mention artillery strike that ruin the game too much.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
work on save and continue option please...(without losing ribbon or rank) also try to make tank and jeep fire more offen they like fire 1 time every 10mins...too slow... i was wondering if its possible for you to design a apc(all-personal carreir) which can fire and cary your troops. Also make a tutorial on the troops more infomation about them e.g French resistance hw thy come abt specially....etc... pls fix the bug for concentrate fire it still have the tactical point needed.. why not also add a timer to known when the next german wave is coming..also you should try assigning shortcuts to th game e.g french(f) artially 1
there should be also a difficulty level e.g easy-med-hard... but ribbons obivously must be affected.. or training mode/tutorial..
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The artillery strike... Hmm... Did you mean for peoples games to always end with an artillery strike? It is quite frustrating. After having happen several times now, with a fairly small deployment (admittedly including a tank), I have to say, its a real game ruiner. Yes, I could have probably gone for a thousand waves without the artillery strike, but its frustrating, especially within the first 50 and probably within the first 100 or even 150 waves to get hit by artillery. And I've made it that far. There is no way to prepare before wave 50, and still have a sustainable squad. I'd call that a balance issue.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Let engineer repair tank and jeep, this is real in life right? Also tank still can catch fire by buring guys, is this a bug?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Actually, while I find the artillery realistic, I also think it makes the game extremely difficult and frustrating. Nothing turns me off for the night like having my promising team blow up by artillery that I couldn't have done any better preventing.
In my best game, the artillery only fired twice in 150 waves and never hit. Perhaps we could move the first artillery strike back a whole bunch of waves for the first 2 ops? No artillery before 50 or something?... And a wave counter.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
haha i got 2538 points in one game and in the same game onwe of my specops got 99 exp trust me the ultimate soldier is a specops with a BAR maching gun and it may not be quite as powerful as a tank but for 20 tp u can get a tank but 4 22 tp u can get 2 specops with BARs!!!!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
lol i found a typo, if you give grenades to a solder that already has grenades, it says "This soldier already have grenades.."
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Seriously, ,my tank just sat there and let the enemy tank shoot it for about 5 minutes. It never once fired back.
Also, I had two soldiers and a tank. One sniper at 70+experince, and one regular infantry at 70+experience. Both at 200HP. They were just mopping up level after level...then suddenly the entire battlefield was bombed black. Kiss the awesome soldiers good-bye.
That's not particularly fun...
Also, I freaking cleared so many levels...up to the first tank...and I still didn't get promoted? What gives?
Please post a scale of promotion. Also what the little insignias on the soldiers mean. I'm not military and I can't tell rank by stripes.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I got the Bronze Star twice, but only one is showing up in my Ops area. Also, I had won a ribbon that gave me a 1% chance of getting a free soldier when I ordered a soldier, but that ribbon disappeared when I got the Medal of Honor...WTF?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
jeeps are GLITCHY
1. they are SLOW, i mean their jeeps, they should be fast
2. i had them suddenly lose all its guys
3. i've also had them freeze, they wont move, but didnt get hit for anything
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
And, of course, that's why it would make sense to encourage beginning players with more TP during their first campaigns as well.
Artillery may well be overpowered when it comes to men in trenches and bunkers. On the other hand, in long games, players may have the TP remaining to replace and rebuild a deployment.