Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for City Idle

« Back to City Idle

MjN18

Aug. 08, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Names are needed in this game.

+ - !

(0)

msaga1

Aug. 07, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) OOH, to fix the glass sand issue, an upgrade to pottery- glass cups! I have so much space dedicated to the clay trade to support the old research establishments xd so a way to sub out the need for clay on pots would be cool.

+ - !

(0)

msaga1

Aug. 07, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Ohh, also did come across some late game crashes if you run the game too long or something. the game starts stuttering at high speed and if you keep going it did crash one time. a refresh fixes it so seems like it's probably something not getting purged or a rounding error building really slowly. only crashes game not browser.

+ - !

(0)

msaga1

Aug. 07, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) only odd part, is you offer so much sand, but like only used to make the final house? I mean maybe electricity uses sand, haven't reached that yet.

+ - !

(0)

SenshiNoRyu

Aug. 04, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Broken Colonies makes it impossible to expand - I'm out of here :/

+ - !

(0)

crazo777

Jul. 29, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) What unlocks animal research? It's at 0/0.

+ - !

(-1)

Blinxies

Jul. 29, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) I am so so so happy you are back with a new game Baldurans, if you were to sell them on steam, i would totally buy it. your factory idle and reactor idle was one of the best concept so far, and trying to look after you, that when i found you you were making city idle. you have no idea how happy i am to know you are back.

+ - !

(0)

Cabeluto

Jul. 27, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) everyone diod in my eastest island. what happened? how can i recover? lots of houses but population doesnt grow back. i´ve just closed every business not essential, and they dont come back.

+ - !

(3)

CaptainLo05

Jul. 26, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) I seem to be having an issue where sometimes boats are abandoned at incomplete colonies with items in them, and no one comes to unload them. Is this a bug or will they eventually get unloaded?

+ - !

(3)

mattyizzo

Jul. 25, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Tips/tricks?

+ - !

(-1)

gamahr

Jul. 24, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Is it just me or there's no structure to hold sugar?

+ - !

(1)

toroidal

Jul. 21, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Is it just me, or does it seem like fishing harbors with schooners are about as efficient as fishieries with small boats? I mean, I guess I can put 11 in a harbor as opposed to 8 in the fishery, but it seems like there should be a bit more of an efficiency increase than that. It's not like you would need to build more than one of either to support a pretty large population.

+ - !

(0)

juhhh

Jul. 21, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) I think that should have some way to set trade routes manually. Sometimes the algorithm is kind of dumb, an I have some storages totally full, and the same item missing in other places...

+ - !

(0)

Kwaker76

Jul. 19, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Aw man ! The recent change to the way houses work has broken my world. Sudden lack of accommodation and therefore people to fill jobs means my whole system is collapsing

+ - !

(1)

DenisKortnev

Jul. 17, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Is it intended that some upgrades are impossible to research? Like there is just no way to store 1 trillion science papers :/

+ - !

(0)

DenisKortnev

Jul. 16, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) ^ great fire only works for people in shelters ;)

+ - !

(0)

DenisKortnev

Jul. 16, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) What a great game! <3 Love the style, the progression, the tech tree! Curious to see if my browser will be able to handle full colonization

+ - !

(0)

zovjraar

Jul. 15, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) would like to have food and water listed somewhere... it's cumbersome to click on everyone to see that they're getting fed.

+ - !

(0)

dadam01

Jul. 14, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) I think I got a bug with a colony, they need 4 planks, there is a boat with them nearby but nothing happens, the dock is free. The colony's stats show "1% of stocks filled" and nothing happen. Deleted docks to do it back, still nothing

+ - !

(0)

Runny99

Jul. 07, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) When will the game be released on steam?

+ - !

(0)

oldsoldier122

Jul. 06, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Brickmaker won't go and get tools...bug? First one built, it just gathers material but never makes bricks because there are no tools (it has two tool sheds on each side, just wood ones but I think those should work).

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Baldurans

It needs stone tools. On tools section there is a tooltip that shows what tools building can operate with. I need to make it more clear :)

oldsoldier122

Jul. 05, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Great game, I love it! I think I may have found a bug. Hut doesn't detect great fire, always reads 0%.

+ - !

(0)

Jaundice

Jul. 01, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Put this on Steam, I'd buy it.

+ - !

(0)

atfc0901

Jun. 17, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) game crashed, loaded save, game keep crashed. I've read in older comments that this has happened before to some people. The error says: Error: Expected ForeverAction, but had Hs: at Vs.finishCurrentForeverAction (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:180940) at li.onFinish (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:212323) at Le.finish (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:50941) at hr.startedActionFinished (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:183656) at Le.start (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:50771) at hr.startedActionFinished (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:183940) at Ge.tick (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:56436) at ho.tick (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:397890) at Do.onTick (coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:416915) at coreAndGraphics.c9897d48.js:1:454214

+ - !

(0)

Ndude3

Jun. 14, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Most games that I play, I hope that they will meet, or even exceed, my expectations. Games by Baldurans, on the other hand, I go in knowing that they will easily exceed my expectations. Great work on this one man, keep doing what you're good at

+ - !

(3)

toroidal

Jun. 14, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) So will there be an ETA on new content? Sort of stuck after building out libraries for 120M. Really doesn't seem like anything else is possible ATM.

+ - !

(0)

jcheung

Jun. 12, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) after way too long, discovered fullscreen. so the previous issue is only if you're not fullscreened.

+ - !

(1)

jcheung

Jun. 11, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) bug: if harbor has max worker upgrade, something in each export&import, export, import, you can't see import. || possible fix, add scrollbar. || on an unrelated note, having some trouble with my population. have an area that has plenty of food and water production/import, was running fine for 12 hours. added an area loosely connected which pushed around 1.5k pop into the island, aforementioned area refuses to keep pop. what conditions need to be met to reproduce? some houses get up to 11 pop and then they just die of old age with all needs except for bread met, then an hour or two passes and it's back up to 11 pop again.

+ - !

(0)

JWBSoftware

Jun. 08, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) You've not removed the block on Safari. Playing the game right now with Safari, just expanding to a new island as I've unlocked colonisation. Game works just fine with the latest version, 16.5, on a MacBook Air M1. Only oddity is it works much better with a mouse as one mistouch on the trackpad and it zooms in or out which is then hard to undo. It could do with keyboard shortcuts for zooming in and out.

+ - !

(0)

dexter81

Jun. 07, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Graphic updates. Although still waiting for further gaming updates.

+ - !

(0)

Jezebel666

Jun. 06, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Awesome game! But I seem to have a problem with the harbour. I can't remove a item from the import/export list. When deselecting both options the item is automatically placed in export. It only appears to be visual but made me check manually very often. And over 2500citizens I got frame drops which were to be expected. But considering how good it ran until that point I believe you to be the wizard that can fix that! Anyway, thanks Baldurans, I loved it!

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Baldurans

It puts it there if you have existing stockpile so people can "empty" it. It most probably is not a bug. About 2500+ population, some slow down is expected, but thinking of a technique to make it faster even with that population, but not sure it will work out :)

italosp99

Jun. 05, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) The game is great, but i can't do any upgrades on the wheat, mill and bakery

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from Baldurans

These upgrades are bound to an achievement.

evoluchien

Jun. 04, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Learning from the discord, if you are only aiming for the badges: Get to colonization and then rush colonization over to the right-hand islands. Beyond the small one there is a massive one, where you can build basics (houses, water, berries, woodcut, wood tools) and very quickly boost your population. In about 5 hours of play time I went from just about 1000 population and I'm now over 2300 and closing in on the badge, with plenty of empty area to continue expanding to until I'm finished.

+ - !

(-1)

Herblaw

Jun. 03, 2023

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-3)

Developer response from Baldurans

Well I tried to reason it :) A bit sarcasm to this, but I guess rating basically "free" stuff negatively because of own choices is a new norm :P

bczretribution

Jun. 02, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) additional QOL suggestions: pipes should also be on the side panel with roads and bridges. when in the pipe placement overlay, a color coded outline that highlights buildings that can draw from pipes, and changes colors to indicate if it is connected to the grid or not

+ - !

(1)

briannenchev

Jun. 01, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) I found such a good strategy. First, you place A LOT of libraries on the map, then you use your great scientist. Each library increases storage by a whole lot.

+ - !

(0)

BergeronS

Jun. 01, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) This game seems bugged right now, you can't buy floating devices and a lot of other research later, the game displays 000 as the cost to buy.

+ - !

(1)

bczretribution

Jun. 01, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) QOL suggestion: docks should be on the quick access side panel next to roads and stairs and bridges

+ - !

(0)

heman

May. 30, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) no more upgrade :[[[

+ - !

(0)

kiss_of_kill

May. 24, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Don't give up on firefox support please!

+ - !

(65)

Developer response from Baldurans

I will not! There is a way to play it with firefox, but it just lags.

candlestick88

May. 23, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Anyone else unlock stone roads and try to replace them all at once only to realize it would tie up every worker without anyone to mine stone and decimate your population? No? Just me then...

+ - !

(17)

Sir_Poopington

May. 23, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Game doesn't fit in screen

+ - !

(2)

stevenmccoy92

May. 20, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) ? For you Developer, my Luxury Research seems to be stuck at 30021, even with multiple campuses and libraries, free-thinking ranges and etc, collecting the research papers. Is there a way to fix this?

+ - !

(2)

JWBSoftware

May. 19, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) I can't post on the official site so I'll post here. The game now works with Safari, with the ?safari=1 switch (which is why I need to play at cityidle.com). Mac OS got an update today with an update of Safari to 16.5 at the same time so I don't know if that is what fixed it. Managed to play for most of an hour without a hitch

+ - !

(4)

JediJoel006

May. 18, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Amazing game once again from you :) Glad to see kong still alive and kicking with you

+ - !

(1)

briannenchev

May. 15, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Can you make it so that docks don't block water for waterworker huts?

+ - !

(3)

Tenshi_Samshel

May. 15, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Pretty good game, enjoying it. Unless I'm missing it: would be nice to add a performance mode or the like. Don't always need to see the people running around, and I presume it slows the game down?

+ - !

(0)

XUep7

May. 13, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) It doesn't seem to be an issue for others, but I need more info visible. Like, clicking a building to tell me what building it is, many are just brown, or (when stuck) brown in fog instead. Also show (describe) its states - e.g. "Hiring" is self-explanatory, but cogwheels no idea what I am supposed to fix. Like I changed berry farms to grains, and most of it is just "?" state. Also it let me place Campus, but do I have bricks or boards, can I even produce these atm?

+ - !

(2)

Cabeluto

May. 12, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) The ships just dont work to me. Ive built docks, shipyards, the ships were fabricated, they are stopped at the docks, there is products defined to import export but they dont move, the crew dont get in.

+ - !

(4)

genius11

May. 11, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) really hope sometime there will be an upgrade to get 2 Cobblestone/Limestone like there is for the ores

+ - !

(0)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate