Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Firestone Idle RPG

« Back to Firestone Idle RPG

Fromanx

Aug. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) So im kinda really annoyed that alchemy is all random. I'm using extremely valuable resources for random chance of getting the two good ones. If you've seen how many of the same epic boots i get you know this game isn't random. Why is it random at all? Why can't we pick and choose like everything else?

+ - !

(3)

lBIGMAMAl

Aug. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) @fenando123asd I have no clue what is your problem, period. :/

+ - !

(0)

Kunjaku

Aug. 22, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Hello Holiday :) We desperatly need a gold dropped during last 30 seconds counter next to the dps one to help make sure you are farming on your optimal lvl. And maybe a more efficient offline mode. A feature I would love to see to is that if squads become idle without any missions available on the map they go contribute to something in the main farm. like maybe a small multiplier or something.

+ - !

(5)

fernando123asd

Aug. 22, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) @BIGMAMAI opened 5 chests. It didn't work. Even refreshed the page, still not there.

+ - !

(0)

lBIGMAMAl

Aug. 22, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) @fernando123asd I found that bug too. Don't worry, if you proceed to open another chest, the chest you "lost" will reappear.

+ - !

(0)

fernando123asd

Aug. 20, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) ok, just discovered this bug. If you click to open a chest, and then press esc, you go back to main page, loses the chest but don't gain anything. The chest simply disappear. Just lost an epic chest.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from HolydayStudios

you do not lose anything, if you go back to open a chest you will continue unboxing it. If you close the game you will instantly get the things contained, so again it's safe.

fischbaua

Aug. 17, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) auto-use for abilities would be so nice

+ - !

(5)

AezurX

Aug. 15, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Please tune down P2W elements and balance guardian damage to always be useful when we are online, I sorta like this game, but it's way to grindy and things like guardians are really unbalanced. Fire tokens also become too expensive too fast and there's no way to reset the fire tokens tree or move points around

+ - !

(0)

Jbenitex

Aug. 14, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I like it

+ - !

(0)

AezurX

Aug. 12, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Would be nice to see the gold/hour gain somewhere in the UI so we can choose what wave is best. In future updates would be nice to have some kind of upgrade to lower heroes cooldown on their abilites

+ - !

(5)

jasonmxx

Aug. 08, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-9)

Fromanx

Aug. 05, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) So first off great game. It has a decent amount of content, its core elements are great and there are plenty of rewards that make me come back to play. But like what others have said the balance is messed up. Its taken me over two months to complete one research tree and thats with a steady amount of constant play. I'm guessing from how long my first upgrades for the next tree is its gonna take at least a year.

+ - !

(1)

fistoz

Aug. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) You should add the epic chests for 1K gems since you can buy'em through emblems anyway.

+ - !

(0)

Nefareon

Aug. 01, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Fun game

+ - !

(2)

kingsize13

Jul. 31, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Can you pls add GPS depending on stage? thx :)

+ - !

(8)

HallowedFlames

Jul. 30, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-15)

metints

Jul. 28, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-7)

KeitaM6

Jul. 27, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I want a confirmation screen when shortening using a gem I have consumed it with a few clicks cv

+ - !

(2)

12albertini12

Jul. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) avatar items would be excellent

+ - !

(-1)

blahcrayon

Jul. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-4)

blahcrayon

Jul. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-6)

FuriousRage

Jul. 21, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-11)

Invisible_King

Jul. 20, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Run into something that seems like a bit of a bug. If i go straight to missions as soon as my game loads up and collect the mission rewards I get a message telling me to refresh the page and have to do so whenever this occurs. It is quite annoying simply because it takes quite a while to get in game, so having to wait for that loading time a second time is really quite inconvenient.

+ - !

(0)

2Edgar2

Jul. 18, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Try adding WORLD BOSS and GUILD BOSS (only if GUILD is finished creating). Also in GUILD, there should be a GUILD STATS same as HONOR STATS, expect it needs a guild coins.

+ - !

(-1)

fakezero

Jul. 18, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) devs i cannot access to the alchemy lab even if you patched unlocking it for all of us, i got a popup alert on the left side on login allowing me to access to it, and i guess i wasn't the only one, but i cannot access it from the town, so if it was intended to unlock it for all fix it from the city, if it is a bug and it wasn't intended just fix the popups on login

+ - !

(0)

lBIGMAMAl

Jul. 18, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I found a bug in latest update (1.1.8): It is possible to access the Alchemist before level 120 via the notification which appears every time you gather at least 40 strange dust and/or 1,250 exotic coins, or reload the game if you have enough of these above. When you exit the window, you will not be able to access the Alchemist via the town map or hotkey A below level 120 except via notification if you reload or gather enough dust/exo coins, if you don't already have the experiment running. I had to report this because you can do experiments at all stages of the game, which can be exploited and used for cheating, so I hope you fix this ASAP.

+ - !

(-1)

jermud96

Jul. 17, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Alchemist is wayyyy too expensive for what you get out of it.

+ - !

(0)

FreeJee

Jul. 14, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) add button to claim all map missions rewards

+ - !

(153)

fernando123asd

Jul. 13, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) ok, just encountered a weird bug, I used pile and barely got xp from it even though I got a good amount of gold. I had speed and strengh scroll at the same time too. Really a bummer cause I was pushing to lvl 120 and that was my last pile.

+ - !

(0)

Euclidean

Jul. 12, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Some way to open multiple chests at once and/or speed up the chest opening time please.

+ - !

(7)

12albertini12

Jul. 12, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) auto cast spell :D

+ - !

(8)

Turpomann

Jul. 11, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) nice time waster, but too grindy. No way to earn diamonds enough to keep it interesting. Depending too much on p2w.

+ - !

(2)

laugh123

Jul. 09, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) @lBIGMAMAl Many thanks, did not thought of that way of testing, thanks once again for the information!

+ - !

(-1)

lBIGMAMAl

Jul. 09, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) @laugh123 yes. Tested it. Guardian Aura bonuses work even if that guardian is not in use. I.e. if you are using dragon as guardian, the attribute bonuses still apply.

+ - !

(0)

laugh123

Jul. 09, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Does Dragon and the Angel stats stack? Thanks.

+ - !

(1)

SpookRooster

Jul. 08, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-7)

wcli789

Jul. 08, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) should be nice if there is a screen for total bonuses from all sources.

+ - !

(1)

Tulak

Jul. 08, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) good performance optimalization

+ - !

(0)

brenigan

Jul. 06, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) LEVEL UP X1000 S'IL VOUS PLAIT !!!!

+ - !

(-1)

quintenmurry

Jul. 05, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) a good game to waste ur time on

+ - !

(1)

antonraymaekers

Jul. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) does anyone know what the drop rates are for the random chest drop in the map missions? is it possible to gain epic or legendary chests from them?

+ - !

(2)

lol138

Jul. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Tassadarwizard don't get your hopes up. Once they decide to make a new game, they will stop updating. They have not updated Holyday city reloaded in well over a year. They don't even respond to questions anymore.

+ - !

(3)

tassadarwizard

Jul. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I have to say, for an idle game, the devs are constantly rolling out new updates. I'm not the most dedicated player but there is lots of added content over time. Also: WHAT IS THE OBELISK

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from HolydayStudios

it's something that is coming in the future, among other features we design :)

Psyleck

Jul. 02, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) We need a Gold Per Second (GPS) indicator on the main HUD.

+ - !

(3)

Nimue

Jul. 02, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-3)

Developer response from HolydayStudios

the game auto-saves every 8 seconds on your local computer and every 2 minutes on your cloud. If you are in a hurry to close the game go to Settings and do a manual save before exiting the game!

Boilrigger

Jul. 01, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-7)

albertros753

Jul. 01, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I quit. Here is why. After reaching lvl 325 you dont even get another slot for the new hero. In addition it has slow attack speed. The scaling is far too high after lvl 200. Only epic chests are worth opening while all others just give you materials in the end. The worst is that achievement boni award you after reaching a certain lvl just +1% or less to a stat. Finally after you have overcome a wall there is no reward which is especially true for higher lvls. In the end I have to say that your heroes shouldnt miss every 2nd attack.

+ - !

(2)

snotmerchant

Jun. 30, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I figured out the issue I had with the firestone tree. Did not realize it scrolled further to the side.So in fact I did not complete the 1st tree yet

+ - !

(2)

rY17

Jun. 30, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Why do upgrades for the overall stats, above the guardian upgrade, deduct more than it shows? Had 17m coins for a 2.7m upgrade and my coins got down to 9m.

+ - !

(0)

Developer response from HolydayStudios

you probably bought more than 1 when you clicked based on your Level Up mode button (at the bottom of the upgrades menu)

Nyzym

Jun. 29, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-5)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2025 Kongregate