Under rating threshold (hideshow)
It not necessary, more of a minor complaint but it would be nice to see how much of the given world is left before we reach the next keymaster. Just simply so its easier to judge if slugging through say 330 of the same mob to advance will be worth the trouble or if should ascend and try again next time. If I was say for example on mob 17/20 that I could visibly see, I can judge if pushing be worth the hassle for a ascension tier unlock.
I plan on adding a "monster number", so you know how far you are into a zone. However, I do want to leave Keymaster location somewhat unknown, that way you're always wondering how close you are, and it adds some suspense. Of course, just like with all things in this game, if enough people want the keymaster location revealed, I will do it.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Love it! Lot of depth to this game, well polished, good mechanics, and a dev that communicates with players and makes updates! Pretty obvious dev's put a lot of time and thought into this. Look forward to seeing where it goes. 5/5!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I think it would be cool if you kept your unlocked zones from key masters kills. I think it would take some of the grindiness out of the ascension without defeating the purpose of the reset. Either needs that or an auto progress cause having to wait for kills is too tedious. Totally unrelated to the first point I also think it would nice to be able to see your inventory of mined ores and fish somehow on the smith screen. would be helpful in making choices. I know the second one is a lot to put on the page but maybe a toggle like on the fishing screen
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I like the new update, but I noticed my screens don't update their levels until I click through each of the activities, then after a second or so it'll jump to the proper level.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The Midas skill seems entirely not worth it. At level 1 it gives you roughly 1.25 extra kills worth of gold every 120 seconds (so even at level 5, an extra kill every ~20 seconds on average _of active play_ is a hard meh). Am I missing something?
5 seconds of 20 clicks per second = 100 clicks. At level 5, it gives 20% of monster gold per click, so 20 Monster's worth of gold.
Go to the vault, and oh boy, THATS A LOTTA DAMA---er, gold!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
So, a question: Why am I not able to upgrade some things in the forge despite having the materials for it? The stomach-thingy being a prime example.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I did a mistake i did ascended but i forgot to use my ap points RIP so i have to wait for my next ascended tbh why can't you have a leave button for the portal
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
4/5 While I love your dedication to this game, and the changes you have made so far, I can't give it a full 5 becuase I don't know what a lot of the stuff does. There needs to be some kind of information given. For example, the little ghost and candies I've been picking up...What is the 1.1% chance they are giving me? Chance for what? What are these things? What do they do? There is no explanation for it, it's just there.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Also this may just be my opinion, but new trainers should be objectively better to invest in than old ones, which is not the case right now as the most valuable seems to always be the first. Core game is solid now though
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
so gold rates on enemies dont rise fast enough to where it makes sense to kill any enemy except the one you can one shot, basically if theres a chance you need 2 strikes to kill an enemy you will get more gold going for the enemy closest below your min damage
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
i put 20 bucks in to support game some things i would like to see, currently fishing off screen as well as mining doesn't give xp it does however give ore and fish, also a manual save option, also something different with event shop, more powerful boosts not sure tbh but feels a bit off ya know,also moving everything to 100% on all screens would be cool (just a suggestion) still playing like the game a lot 5/5 from me but have to nit pick the small things ;) also would love for some sounds effects/music
You're support goes a long way to helping me continue working on the game Mesakaro :) ------------------------------------------ 1. Fishing/mining off-screen gives xp for me, so I'd need more info as to why this isn't working for you. ------------------------- 2. The game auto-saves every 60 seconds, and also saves every time you visit a screen. ------------------------------------- 3. The event shop needs a lot of work, and I agree more powerful/diverse boosts would be very cool! --------------------- 4. Can't do sounds/music, because I have 0 experience with sound design/composition :( ---------------------------------- Thanks again for supporting the game!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
looks like awesome game, 5/5, and as you state that you gonna dedicate and update i would really like to give you more!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Also, as many have said, tooltips. Tooltips are sorely needed in this game. What do Blacksmith pills do? I don't know, it doesn't say.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The 'Minor Investment' crafted item which gives you money per minute seems rather underpowered. Even at the point I was able to make it I was needing many hundreds of thousands to upgrade things a single level. The tiny trickle of money that perk brings in is negligible even at higher levels.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
As with the other game, the UI is killing me. I like the game but the UI feels more messy then it even is. Also some tooltips would help.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
What's the point of not having a back button on the ascend screen? The text even calls out that you have to refresh to leave, which is a super weird thing to acknowledge rather than fix.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Would be great tooltips or a better " ? " section.... for example i cant find what to do skills like "Vision"
Great game btw :D 5/5
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Not gonna lie. This game confused the heck out of me until I realized I'd misread the title and this wasn't Idle Skiing.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
How many mobs are there in the desert? Killing 310 mobs to find out there's just another 330 to kill is extremely tedious when you've no idea how much longer you have to do this.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
My first impression of the game was well the rating, i nearly just turned away to never play this game at all. But I didn't and totally don't regret it because it is an amazing game both content and quality wise, indeed it was slow at first but I still kept playing because I knew it'll only get better. And yes it did I personally think this game has reached an amazing point to where it indeed only will get better, and to those who did rate this game 1* please reconsider your one-sided comment because it is an amazing game and I know it was slow but just because of that doesn't mean it is a bad game. Furthermore good fortune and I hope this game will get a better rating because it deserves it.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
You're making good improvements on this game. Could you make it so clicking the time warps in fishing doesn't remove the upgrade menu? I am interested to see where this game is heading!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Once in a while comes a game that despite the pay to win option just has to have 5* for the sheer amount of work, developer response and game play. This diamond in the rough is such a game.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I feel like on ascension, the power+ seems to stay same cost but I think it also keeping the fish power gained from it? Least I started with more fish power than I believe I should have.
This has been fixed in the new update I posted 30 minutes ago! On the next ascention, you should find that Power LV's are reset, and the costs are back to starting values!
Google play is very finicky with new games. Idle Skilling was released 2 days ago, and it usually takes games 3-4 days to show up in the search bar. So for anyone reading this, check the google play store in a day or two and you will see it!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
"This man shows potential, I will train him till he can defeat death himself."
"Really? I didn't think being slaughtered by a snail classified as potential. Or by a bush."
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I love the update to the non-active screens! It went from feeling to chaotic and busy to feeling like I had lots of fun things to fiddle with. This game is amazing now and one of my favourite idle games so far. Thanks for much for all your work and your quick response to all the feedback!
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Ascension seems to give too low of a bonus and increase in cost too fast, where right now it's not overly valuable to ascend
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I would advice reduceing by 50% all gain and make active windows have 100% production value
less frustration for player, still same balance :)
Good luck with your game ^^