Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I agree with Katzazi. This kind is pretty boring and repetitive. Also if you're trying to appeal to young girls you might want to add a bit more variety. Maybe add the option to make cookies, cupcakes and/or brownies.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
If there would be more than one kind of cake to make, or some kind of rating or some kind of cake-show or anything else it could be a game worth do try out. But as it is now, there is no reason to play it more than once.
To bake a real cake is much more fun!
Btw: Why do you need 5 eggs if you only use 2? Why are the ingredients added in this unrealistic order and why do you add all ingredients befor you start to stir at all? And why do you only bake once but get a 3-layer cake by doing so?
The game would get at least some depth if anything of this would be more realistic...