Hugh... defense quests are ridiculous. Sometimes it is just plain impossible to kill every enemy with a certain equipment. And if you don't mind that, they are just TOO EASY.
If you unequip your weapon you will fight with a giant ring, at least while playing as a Golem. Thumbs up to keep this superfunny glitch (or perhaps easteregg?) noticed so more people can see it.
the best one is still number 2. This one is awful for battle (wtf my priest is intended for magic and physical damage combined, but I chose it because when I started as a rogue, having in mind that daggers of high quality give me bonuses, I used daggers but... surprise! they do also magic damage! so she tries to kill a skeleton with 3-damage magic instead of 17-damage dagger attacks!! Oh, and like on protector 1, we all follow the same road: combat training, sweeping and resting the least possible.