WOW. Not sure if this happened to anyone else, but I was rummaging through a dresser, not really thinking about what I was doing, just kind of on auto-pilot, so I grabbed everything that wasn't useful and exited the loot screen. After I closed it, it said "10/25 junk items picked up" and I thought "I didn't pick up any junk..." so I opened my inventory, checked out my junk tab and I had just picked up a bottlecap. I play way too much Fallout.