Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for The New Idle Blacksmith

« Back to The New Idle Blacksmith

jester2369

May. 02, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) Lost another 600 ascension levels because the stupid "save" doesn't work.

+ - !

(2)

jester2369

Apr. 13, 2023

Under rating threshold (show) "Cloud Save" only works periodically. Just lost 70 ascension levels because the cloud save hasn't actually saved an of my progress over the last 3 days- and I try to save my progress at least twice a day minimum. This version is having the same issue as the first game. Until it gets fixed, my rating will continue to be a 1 star because that's the lowest we're allowed to rate it.

+ - !

(0)

Junx72

Jul. 30, 2022

Under rating threshold (show) Uncaught RangeError: Maximum call stack size exceeded

+ - !

(2)

LordKAT4714

Jul. 14, 2022

Under rating threshold (show) Unplayable call stack size exceeded

+ - !

(2)

lorddryst

Nov. 09, 2021

Under rating threshold (show) Would love to see this updated with fresh content. I know its old but still good

+ - !

(1)

Duck2B

May. 23, 2021

Under rating threshold (show) A game in WebGL! this game creator Knew the only way to make a stable game for the Future! Someone should pay him/her to rebuild this game, and make it better and brighter.

+ - !

(4)

Nakhor

Oct. 21, 2020

Under rating threshold (show) daym son how many armies are we supplyng?

+ - !

(1)

heman6661

Sep. 30, 2020

Under rating threshold (show) spark is stupid

+ - !

(-1)

jumpingspider

Aug. 24, 2020

Under rating threshold (show) On Firefox, javascipt errors are happening every time the game loads

+ - !

(-2)

jumpingspider

Aug. 16, 2020

Under rating threshold (show) This game is riddled with java errors on Firefox.

+ - !

(-1)

koreybazan

May. 12, 2020

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-3)

adolfoc130

Dec. 21, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Best Game Ever! Sad to see it´ll be gone by 2020

+ - !

(1)

poisontaww

Dec. 16, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) New Idle Blacksmith just freezes up at loading screen for me at 3/4 of the way done. Not like it's going to be fixed anyways, so why I bothered is beyond me.

+ - !

(-2)

Gentleman3745

Aug. 25, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-5)

stickmankiller45

Jul. 26, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) I'd say add a new tier of metal as a reference to SCP: Telekill.

+ - !

(0)

Mineforce270

Jul. 12, 2019

Under rating threshold (show)

+ - !

(-9)

stickmankiller45

Jul. 10, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) My progress has failed to load several times now, forcing me to load my latest save to recover lost progress. This is getting rather annoying, please fix this bug so others like me don't have to go through this annoyance day after day. Also, message to all players: save, save, SAVE often!

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Jun. 29, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Perhaps a legendary system like Skyrim for the Ascension skills? The skills can be reset on every Ascension rank up, and would get a slight boost in power each time, like maybe a 10% boost. The player's points would be refunded, and would allow the player to either distribute their points or bank them in the boosted skill. Allows for some creative player setups.

+ - !

(-1)

stickmankiller45

Jun. 27, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Heh, seems cryptonium is a reference to the cryptocurrency. Guess I'll also make a sword out of bitcoins. Should be sharp. *sarcasm*

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Jun. 26, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) My suggestion of a small fractional increase in speed per level is intended to benefit all players, but especially AFK players, who leave it running offline for hours at a time, then come back and either progress a lot (enough upgrades, or early-game) or find they've hit a brick wall (not enough upgrades, or late-game and upgrades are too expensive). Especially when the late-game players find it difficult to rack up the levels needed to generate more ascension skill points.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Jun. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Okay, seems there's a bug that causes the game to fail loading my progress, meaning I get stuck with the tutorial unless I manually load my progress from the settings menu.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Jun. 11, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) There's a bug I found while playing: Randomly my progress seems to not load, leading to me occasionally having to reload my progress manually in-game. The game should reliably reload progress, so that people like me aren't tricked into thinking their progress was erased somehow.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

May. 27, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Could there possibly be a sell all enchanted items button? Like there is for ores and stuff? Sometimes the automated system makes thousands of swords or mail or boots overnight and holding down the sell button, even on the fastest setting with the boosts active doesn't sell em near fast enough. Would really help.

+ - !

(1)

stickmankiller45

May. 24, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Adamatium? I think you mean Adamantium, mrcaboom.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

May. 16, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Suggestions for better progression: Each level adds 0.0001% to base mining speed, so it gets progressively better for early game ores, but still remains a challenge to mine the later ores. Also, perhaps a linear cost increase system instead of exponential to lessen the burden of upgrading. Increasing to trillions in cost to upgrade the merchant is a bit much early on.

+ - !

(1)

stickmankiller45

May. 07, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Perhaps include sound effects for the buttons? Like a pickaxe sound for the miner, a flickering flame sound for the smelter, hammer & anvil sound for the blacksmith, a magical sound for the enchanter, and a cha-ching sound for the merchant. Would make it much better.

+ - !

(1)

stickmankiller45

May. 06, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Well, broke the save button. Not sure what to do now.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

May. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Mrcaboom, seems there is a bug with high score submission. It submitted my business rank high score when I reached 4, but after that, no submission. Any chance you could fix this?

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

May. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Perhaps upgrades that could reduce cooldown times for spells? I occasionally use them to speed up my progress.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Apr. 27, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Any idea why I haven't gotten a new high score yet? My Business Rank is 144, yet my only high score is at 3. WTF?

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Apr. 16, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Anyone looking for sell lowest ore can sell craft materials at business level 10. I'm aiming for it myself, so I can sell off ore and ingots I'm no longer using to level up.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Apr. 16, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Well, there's the recursion error. Thankfully I saved my progress to the cloud. We'll see.

+ - !

(0)

stickmankiller45

Apr. 13, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Seriously, would love to sell my cheap ores like copper and iron, as having this much could make me rich quick if sold.

+ - !

(1)

stickmankiller45

Apr. 13, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) amlit, this is the most recent, as it is kinda a reboot of the first game.

+ - !

(-1)

stickmankiller45

Apr. 13, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) My only gripe with this game is that progress doesn't stick, even cloud saved progress is wiped on refresh. 1 star until this is fixed.

+ - !

(2)

tznetbrolly

Mar. 27, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) it crashes very often :((

+ - !

(0)

S12107A

Mar. 18, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) First time playing very pleased

+ - !

(0)

zomthehunter

Feb. 23, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Java error says too much recursion every time I reach 1000$ and when i refresh, all of my progress is wiped.

+ - !

(2)

amlitintwin12345

Feb. 22, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Hey dev, I’m confused a little bit. Is this the most recent game, or is it idle blacksmith 2? I’m kinda late to the party. I like to play the most recent gams, by with the naming, it’s hard to tell.

+ - !

(1)

Eamb

Feb. 04, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) Java errors every time i play on every refresh and data gets wiped. Unplayable broken game.

+ - !

(2)

berttren7867

Jan. 16, 2019

Under rating threshold (show) can i plez get moe sells

+ - !

(0)

Toksyuryel

Nov. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Game consistently crashes every time I try to sell for "very cheap"

+ - !

(1)

aguafriayerrett

Nov. 21, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Java error; too much recursion. Happened twice in 10 minutes. Unfavoriting and lose one star until fixed.

+ - !

(1)

fireaxe0

Oct. 07, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) great

+ - !

(0)

tsesarevich

Sep. 27, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) Yeah this glitches out regularly with 'too much recursion' and breaks. I figure that's what the guy in August was getting at.

+ - !

(2)

mirbulandkhan

Sep. 23, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) i wish i had saved this games data because it deleted for me :... (

+ - !

(0)

mirbulandkhan

Sep. 22, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) an easy trick just sell mails not any thing else it is easy and much better

+ - !

(0)

jarjarbuggle

Aug. 26, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) too much recursion

+ - !

(2)

CaptianR

Jul. 23, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) i have a phew thought so far of this game wich is id like to see how much work is in a number so i can grapse a number so when i upgrade i can get the idea how long each will get and how much upgrades id need to a desireable idle rate secondly for a moment im not shure if this is just me or not but i noticed some tiems my computer did not take me trying to over power the weakest ones to well w/ autos becase ever so often for a moment it basicly froze to try to process all that is going on just thought id let you know @MRCABOOM

+ - !

(0)

csquire

Jun. 28, 2018

Under rating threshold (show) I agree I like the first one more

+ - !

(1)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Code of Conduct
© 2026 Kongregate