Games Achievements My Kong Sign In

Comments for Treasure of Cutlass Reef

« Back to Treasure of Cutlass Reef

HadroLepton

Oct. 05, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) needs an option to change quality

+ - !

(0)

TrickyWarlord2

Oct. 05, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Better than Sid Meir's Pirates. ER, nearly.

+ - !

(0)

GoldEagle

Oct. 05, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) this is pretty awesome :) but like some people have said needs to be less repetative 4/5

+ - !

(0)

xima51

Oct. 05, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) No fun with that stupid AI! It should shot on vertical and diagonal also... Actually a good game, but gets repetitive at least to the lvl I got. Firing on the wrong side doesnt happen too often, one annoying thing though is my ship not getting to the upper side of the screen.

+ - !

(0)

PheelACCD

Oct. 05, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Cool game, great graphics. Need to be faster and less repetitive. 4/5

+ - !

(0)

ttobbaa

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) m'kay- got another one- only 2 ships on the screen- mine and enemy flag ship- I'm full on broadside to his bow, and ALL MY GUNS FIRE ON THE WRONG SIDE!!! Yikes!! I like this game- I really do. Unfortunately, I really like reading about accounts of ship to ship actions, too- sometimes it's annoying to know too much about a topic. If you want ideas about how to make this more "realistic" gimme a holler- I enjoy the game as is (fun shooter- too bad it gets several orders of magnitude harder at the end), but I'd really like help this be a "real" naval combat game, if that's what you're after.

+ - !

(0)

Schmee1_2

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Like the game! its been along time since I have seen a Flashgame like this one...however.. As others have said, The ability to go all over the screen, maybe difrent ships for the player?... And guys for a storie, they are PIRATES after the TREASURE :-)

+ - !

(0)

AcidFlux

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Quite enjoyable. 4/5

+ - !

(0)

yourmajesty18

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) ignore nearly everything feldspar said except for maybe the story line thing... give us a little character development.

+ - !

(0)

Thundercleze

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) nice game, gets repetetive though, maybe shorter battles and more powerups or somethin

+ - !

(0)

Feldspar

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Needs a story line, slightly faster ships, ability to go past half screen, ability to switch between different ships, the last level shouldn't be 100 times as hard as all the other levels AND shouldn't take 30+ minutes to beat. I like how the ship actually acts like a real ship though, that's more then most pirate games can say. Also: Who am I fighting? British? Spanish? French? Other pirates? And how come they haven't already taken the treasure? And why are they just sitting around? And why doesn't my ship just go around them instead of fighting? And how am I upgrading my ship? And how is my ship magically repaired at the beginning of every level? And why do the ships have so much money on them if they're war ships? And how is it even possible to get the money out of the sunken ships in 3 seconds?

+ - !

(0)

Devonushka

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Very fun and origanal 4/5 *s Favorited!!!

+ - !

(0)

thatmikeykid

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) This is great.. just like the ship combat in Pirates!.

+ - !

(0)

tivaelydoc

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Weird. my cannon stopped working.

+ - !

(0)

xander151

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) awesome!! give it a badge!!

+ - !

(0)

VertFire

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Great game very addicting Ship fighting isn't used in many flash games Great Job.

+ - !

(0)

ljock

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) This game is GREAT!!! Loved it!!!! :)

+ - !

(0)

stealthsilent

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) its just as addictive as line rider

+ - !

(0)

Phoenix00017

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) This game is far, far more entertaining that it deserves to be. I mean that as a compliment. It's so simple, yet the wonderfully amusing and, frankly, satisfying process of blowing the crap out of other vessels is just extremely fun and addictive. I'll only play through once, but I'm having a hell of a time in the process. Well done!

+ - !

(1)

solider23876

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Coffins?

+ - !

(0)

kris1027

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Awesome game. I loved it.

+ - !

(0)

tivaelydoc

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) awesome game! way better then starfighter! 5/5!

+ - !

(0)

rubeo990

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) And Grapeshot isn't explosive, it is more along the lines of a shotgun shell. (The pic is of a little ball with a fuse)

+ - !

(0)

rubeo990

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) You put gold in your Coffers, not your Coffins >_<.

+ - !

(0)

Swish27

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) i like it but it needs more keep working on it and i will rate it higher

+ - !

(0)

Swish27

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) i like it but it needs more keep working on it and i will rate it higher

+ - !

(0)

Makoro_Shimoro

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Fun but slow and boring watching enemys going back and forth make them do more and make the pirate battles more exciting 3/5

+ - !

(0)

efutoran

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) I thought this was going to be like Ancient art of war at sea. Instead its just a shoot em up with wind. No strategy involved.

+ - !

(0)

Onwijs

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) The game looks good, but even on the easy level you're faced with five or more enemies at the same time and it's very frustrating if you have a ship that fires its cannons on the wrong side (to the edge of the screen).

+ - !

(0)

Poo_shoe1

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) lol, you shouls really make this interesting, like give power ups, in game, for shot time only, so maybe, you can go faster?

+ - !

(0)

nate451

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) In a certain sense, this is like a new take on the Alien Invaders theme. Kill the pirates ships before they get close to you. The simplicity made it a bit of a drag to play through the levels... everything was alike, the levels didn't change. But the basic concept was extremely enjoyable. I loved the feel of the cannons and learning to hit the right angles. 4/5.

+ - !

(0)

ernasty10050

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Perhaps it was a bug, but the wind only blew south, and it blew for the entire game. Kind of frustrating. I was pinned to the bottom of the map.

+ - !

(0)

Jezebeau

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) That said, space invaders has never looked better.

+ - !

(0)

Jezebeau

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Good game, but gets rather tedious in the last couple levels. 4/5

+ - !

(0)

Geohyte

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) If I could place, and choose what type of cannons I got that would be great. Overall I like the game, but definitly change the style of enemy ships. Maybe even change the ship you get for every armor upgrade.

+ - !

(0)

zeonic

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) INSANELY slow and boring, got old by the time i beat level 1.

+ - !

(0)

iranaeus

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Pretty fun. Making the cannonballs a little different than debris would help.

+ - !

(0)

ttobbaa

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) I've been waiting for a fairly realistic naval warfare game... this isn't quite it. Interesting anf fun, but needs tweaks- lots of'em. Like- saying what the upgrades are and how much they cost...a wind direction indicator... scrolling map w/mini global map (naval battles need more space than you've got here). If you were going for a fairly novel shooter- you've done well- but I'd love to see a game with more depth and realism.

+ - !

(0)

quinton12123

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Ya the controls are a bit slow

+ - !

(0)

Kurpapyr

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) As a simple game of piracy, I consider it a great game. It has a wonderful gameplay with great wind factors and other influences on the control of the ship. It has some problems, of course, but they can be fixed in a future patch. Altogether, naval battles combined with the thrill of heroic battles and with the fun of piracy, mounted on a good graphical engine and with a beautiful gameplay, makes a hell of a game. It can be expanded into a great game, but as I said, it is a simple game, and it's great as it is.

+ - !

(0)

elondisc

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) awesome

+ - !

(0)

Kouri_no_Kitsune

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Very fun game. Gets a little monotonous after a while. Maybe different ship choices or weapons? Overall, very nice.

+ - !

(0)

partyhardydan

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) or better yet just leave it the way it is and make it like 2v2 you get a random partner :D or you could like make custom teams. or if you can create a Fast enuff server u could make like 4v4 or 2v2v2v2 and make like Crews,gangs,nations,clans ect.

+ - !

(0)

fr0st2k

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) changed to a 4/5 ... mistyped hehe

+ - !

(0)

partyhardydan

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) get a server and make a mass multiplayer version.(ripoff of starfighter game :D)

+ - !

(0)

fr0st2k

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) "Great game! I like this game. I would suggest making it like a mafia game where you defeat pirates to loot their land, and go into major cities to buy cannons, crew ect. The first thing to upgrade would be reloading time, than amt of cannons then crew, it makes the game alot easier." without this .. this game is a 2.5..with that , its a 10/5

+ - !

(0)

The_Chosen_One

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Bit to much minigamish and not enough pirate feeling/game like cutthroats. 3/5.

+ - !

(0)

slasher

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) Great game! I like this game. I would suggest making it like a mafia game where you defeat pirates to loot their land, and go into major cities to buy cannons, crew ect. The first thing to upgrade would be reloading time, than amt of cannons then crew, it makes the game alot easier.

+ - !

(0)

clubp

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) BOOOOOO

+ - !

(-1)

vulcano

Oct. 04, 2007

Under rating threshold (show) great game, should have a badge!

+ - !

(0)

  • add a comment
Developers Players Support YouTube TikTok X (Twitter) LinkedIn
Join the conversation Join Discord
Terms Privacy Code of Conduct
© 2024 Kongregate