Under rating threshold (hideshow)
the time goal is a bit dumb, and you need luck on some levels to get perfect. i never upgraded or even repaired one city, just conquer, push on, build farms get more units. controls could be a bit better, drag and drop is one of the worst possibilities (rts games been around for ages, the ideas are all out there and are generally used).
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Finally made it. Didn't really take /that/ long. But it felt like much longer. I dread to think about what it'll take to do that 4th mission in under 5 minutes 30.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Are we just supposed to lose repeatedly to the Crimson Horde's 4th mission or farm the earlier missions until we get enough 'edicts' to just muscle through?
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The game would be much more enjoyable, if your stupid units would give a shit, what you tell them. I say "Go there and leave the trolls in the way alone" of course they don't...well the heavy melee units do, the heavy ranged ones of course not. Also "Attack Base A" they attac base B "Okay plan change, since you are already attacking B keep doing that"...after killing the enemies they turn around and attack A instead. HOLY SHIT that's the worst umit commanding system I have ever seen in my life! Also: You want perfect ratings? That's easy, just whatever you do: DO NOT ENJOY THE GAME, JUST RUSH, RUSH, RUSH, RUSH, NEVER enjoy the game or you won't get perfect ratings.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
The moment, when you're finishing your enemies just in time, but don't get the Perfect, because the timer goes for two more seconds.....
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
And because they need to go around to the front to enter a town, my Immortals attack the forces of two separate enemies rather than going straight back inside after defending my town.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Oh, my half-health Immortals decided to charge at the 2 groups of gunbots since I can't actually force them to move when they're being attacked.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I love the time challenge! Makes that to need to be creative, take risks and think fast. Although I think most people hate taking risks ^^
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
In the time between completing the mission and actually going to the mission complete screen my rating went from perfect to great.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Soldier: "Commander, the enemy castle is straight ahead."
Commander:"Let's hit that Giants' cave off to the side of the road."
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
I think there may be a problem with scaling the difficulty of levels, considering that a perfect rating requires the same time to complete regardless of which level it is. The levels don't seem to get genuinely harder and I completed most of them with the same basic unit.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Just a 4. Game play is good, but the ability to earn edicts on already completed levels (even just one edict on a replay versus the two for the original) would have pushed it over the top to a 5 for me.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Nice Game!
Some Ideas I would like to share are custom leaders/generals that you can create and battle other players on a huge map, kind of like RISK, except for the custom leaders :P
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Couldn't finish it. The game just makes me rage every time a group doesn't obey my orders or path stupidly. I'm looking forward for the sequel though as this should be easily fixed in it.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Don't like the game because they make it harder and harder but don't give you anymore time to do things for perfect. Don't ever put a achiv like that if you can't make it right.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Volume sliders would be amazing was my first though about this. The SFX are SO LOUD. I want them on, but they just overpower everything.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
[5/5] and very fun, but it's irritating that my troops don't listen to my command when enemies are nearby. Example: I saw a squad of undead heading for my base and sent a few of my squads to defend it. I lost the base because my troops felt like fighting the enemies near them... and then attempting to capture the base that was sending the troops. I think a retreat button/ability and being able to switch squads between Passive Mode and Attack Mode would be an excellent feature in your next game.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
@Toimu: There is a "SKIP" button in the intro at the bottom-right corner. Did you really think a developer would be evil enough to make us watch a movie EVERY time we start their game? : )
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
A multiplayer feature could be interesting. There could be like 4 players in one big map, with the undead also being playable. (I don't know if the undead are actually playable in this game, sense I haven't gotten so far yet).
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
A lot of lag for this simple game on my computer. Selecting multiply units doesn't work most of the time for me. And rushing is the only goal. Could be a good game, only an okay game for me though.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
For the rating indicator, maybe it could show what your rating will be if you continue at the current pace instead of just being a hard indicator? That way, if you fall behind, you'll know before it's too late and can work harder to catch up.
Under rating threshold (hideshow)
Freaken is right. Trebuchet automatically attacks NPCs on path even when they have been told to target something else. They really need to stop attacking when asked to move somewhere else.