Do you play on the same computer as somebody else? Try changing the account, or deleting the browser saved files, or simply play it in a different browser.
I do like the 8 bit style, but I think a more fully fleshed version would really shine on Steam. The menu system can even work with consoles. I would totally do all the new art and port this to XNA myself... the game really deserves better than this tiny box on Kong.
Do you play on the same computer as somebody else? Try changing the account, or deleting the browser saved files, or simply play it in a different browser.